If you love Panera’s Fall Harvest soup which is the same flavor then this is for you!! It is so freaking good. It’s thick and a warning to those who don’t like onions, there are chopped onions in it. It’s sweet and thick and just good!!

I'm obsessed with this soup and am so bummed I can't get it at the moment. Everyone that isn't a fan of squash and has tried this soup has a change of heart.

This is the best soup! Great flavor and texture! My favorite except I cannot find it at the Club do online anymore. I'm so sad. Please bring it back!!

This soup is way too sweet. I tried to save it with herbs and seasoning and nothing helped. I actually had to throw it away and I don't like to waste food. If you don't like sweet soup do not get this.

The soup is delicious a great balance of the squash and the apple to one of the things I look forward to in fall unfortunately, Sam's Club carries it for too short of a time because it would be good to have all winter long

I love this soup. It serves 4 with nice salad and crusty bread. I eat healthy and frequently eat soup for lunch. I make butternut squash soup and I am a very good cook but I have a spinal cord injury and broken my back twice due to falls and it isn't always easy to cook, so this is an excellent way to have my favorite soup. I always have to add something to prepaid soups, but all I added to this was a dash of cream and a 1/2 tsp of chicken base and a splash of maker's mark chicken stock which I keep at least keep 3 cases of onhand--It's that good.

Last fall, this soup was five stars! I kept it in my fridge all the time. This year, it has chunky pieces of onions that are a little crunchy, and the onion overpowers the soup. The soup is delicious, but if you don't like onion-flavored food, this may not be the best choice for you. Please change it back to the 2024 recipe.

The Butternut Squash was sooo tasty!

My favorite fall soup by far. Great for adding smoked chicken as well. The consistency is perfect.

I love this soup as the weather turns cool. Quick, easy, and comforting!