In sifting this with a wire mesh cat box scoop, it is approximately 25% small gravel and not clumping material. The clumping is SO sub par. Remains like wet mud forever. Terrible, terrible purchase even for the lesser price from other products. I've learned my lesson to NEVER buy this litter again.

I use the Members Mark Scented Scoopable Cat Litter all the time for our two indoor cats. I find that it works as well as some of the higher priced name brands. If I could improve it I think that the scent could be a little stronger but all in all I'll continue to use it.

I have bought this litter for years. Over the past year or so, it has changed. It is very dusty now. It no longer clumps, but breaks apart when scooped. I have also noticed it does not hold the odor of my 2 cats. I know I will not get the deal of the Sam's Club price, but it just doesn't do what it claims it does anymore.

I was excited when Sam's came out with a new formula cat litter as I gave the previous formula a shot and it was way too dusty for my cats. Now this new formula is pretty much dust free but now I see litter everywhere as my cats are tracking it like crazy. I would return it if I hadn't already repurposed the bucket. It'll just be shop litter now for my garage.

This litter is horrible! It does not clump to the point and pee but is sticky on your litter box! A total disaster to clean up after. I use everclean for my litter robots and it is hands down amazing! I was looking for something less expensive for an ordinary litter box and found this stuff to be absolutely useless!

This is the WORST cat litter! Covered everything in my office with dust, and had no oder control whatsoever. If you are using for something other than indoor cat box--maybe but don't waste your money trying to save a few dollars. You will just buy another in a few days.

Unless the formula has changed with this new bucket (which I have not yet opened to try), it is TERRIBLE. I used to buy this exclusively and it worked great. A year or two ago something changed, the litter didn't clump and just crumbled apart making it impossible to scoop out liquid waste, which resulted in a NASTY smelling litter box. So I switched to another store brand. We'll see how this newly designed Members Mark bucket does. I'm not holding my breath (but maybe I should?).

It's got bigger rocks than usual mixed in with the sand but I don't complain cause it literally does the same job as all other litters at a great price. Dusty but only for like 5sec and it's not a bad dusty. Cat doesn't seem to mind texture, works great.

I use this in a litter robot where it's critical that it clumps for the robot to scoop away the clumps. This didn't clump at all, I ended up with a litter robot full of pee soaked cat litter. The fresh step Sam's sells is infinitely better. Do yourself a favor and avoid this litter unless you enjoy your house smelling like cat pee everytime you come home.

One of my kittens will pee and poop outside the litter box I assume from the fragrance as I have read. Do they make this in a fragrance free litter? Also I read that any litter containing sodium bentonite or crystalline silica dust are harmful to cats but there are no ingredients labeled on the box and also when googled. I'd like to know what's in it. I'd give it 5 stars if I had these answers