This cat litter does clump urine together, but it breaks up easily leaving smaller granular pieces behind & doesn't shake out well. After several uses, it begins to retain the odors from urine & poop. you have to poor more on to hide the smell, but the smell still exists. don't waste your money, buy the better brands.. I should have returned it!

I picked this up to try and was very disappointed! Doesn’t clump and the odor coming from litter box was horrible. Had to stop using because the whole house was stinking. Also it is very heavy! Taking to garage for oil spills, should work fine for that.

We have used this litter for years in multiple litter boxes for multiple cats. Until recently, it clumped well, held together for cleaning and produced very little dust. Not it just sucks. It causes a dust storm when the cats use it, coating the furniture in the cat room. It doesn't clump well, and what clumps there are fall apart when scooped. Have bought my last of this litter. Cannot recommend that anyone use this product. Bring back the previous product.

Open container and dump in the garbage. Doesn't clump well. Pee clumps fall apart after a very short period. I have to dump out the entire box because of the horrible ammonia smell. Spend the extra $5 and get Tidy Cats brand. Absolute trash wouldn't recommend this to an enemy.

This is the worst litter I've tried. The clumps fall apart when trying to scoop. They break into a million little pieces that leave the whole litter box smelling just awful. The clumps also stay wet and stick to the side of the litter box as well as the scoop. The only nice part is the container it comes in.

Seems like something has changed. This used to work well. Still clumps OK, BUT, 30-40% of the clumps disintegrate as you try to scoop them which contaminates the remaining litter making it smelly. Far too soon you have no choice but to dump all of it. Great price but not a bargain if you use twice as much. If it doesn't change back to previous formula, I will discontinue buying it.

Why did I not read the reviews on this before I bought it?! I was so excited for an affordable 40 pound tub of cat litter that I forgot all about it. I usually find the Member’s Mark brand to be of great quality, but if this is the best they can do they shouldn’t have even tried. If I was a desperate cat lady with no sense of smell then maybe I’d choose this. My whole house smells like cat pee. Now I have 30 something pounds of this crap left that I’ll have to mix in with some tidy cats or something so I don’t waste it. I’d be embarrassed to invite company over. BOOOO.

This litter is absolute garbage. On the bucket, it says four things: Low Dust; Long Lasting Odor Control; Superior Clumping; Fresh Clean Scent. 3 of those 4 things are lies. Incredibly dusty when poured into the litter box, odor control might last a day, barely clumps at all, but it does smell good when you first pour the litter.

I am INCREDIBLY excited to see this product back in Sam’s Club stores. The new and improved product is even better than the former version. The price point, product value, and quality are second to none. PLEASE keep this product in your stores!! The savings and quality are tremendous!! For a multicat household, this is a must-have and consumers absolutely can’t beat the price. To buy anything else is to throw your money away. This works just as well as the name brands with tremendous savings in price.

This litter was disgusting. We got it because the price was good and litter had been hard to find. We usually use tidy cats glade. The smell of this litter was horrible and quality was terrible. My cats hated it so much they pooped outside the box until I threw it away and put tidy cats in which he found online sams. Definitely would not recommend this litter. Zero stars if I could.