Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Chlorinating Granules 50 lbs. for
Member's Mark Chlorinating Granules 50 lbs.
4.5 out of 5 stars
stars
646 ratings189 reviews
  1. 5 stars78% (507)
  2. 4 stars10% (62)
  3. 3 stars4% (26)
  4. 2 stars2% (11)
  5. 1 star6% (40)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 51-60 of 189 reviews
Aug 31, 2018
poolboy
3 out of 5 stars
3 out of 5 stars review

Don't Use It Regulary

This is trichlor. If you are not familiar with the makeup of trichlor, it has stabilizer or CYA in it. Usually the buckets will not say this, even from the pool stores. Continuous use of trichlor will cause your stabilizer to go beyond the max recommended amount which is 50ppm and then you will not be able to add enough chlorine to prevent algae. The only thing you can then do is drain your pool until the CYA level falls. Use liquid chlorine as your normal chlorinating agent. Using 50lbs of this product in a pool season will definetly throw your pool chemistry out of whack.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Jun 6, 2016
Michelley
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible mistake

I bought this at the beginning of May to use for the season. BIG MISTAKE! I went through the entire bucket in 2 weeks without seeing an improvement in the water! Realizing my error, I purchased a different product. And the pool cleared up in 2 days! I would have gone back for a refund, but I used the whole bucket!

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Jul 26, 2016
Systemtech
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Best Chlorinating Granules

This is the best Chlorinating Granules I've used in my pool yet! Don't understand the bad reviews. I have an 8' 25k gal pool and I only put in 1 scoop every other day and it's 100 degrees! It totally dissolves (unlike Leslie's that left half the granules undissolved on the pool bottom). Great product, hope they don't change it.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Jul 3, 2022
Shazam
3 out of 5 stars
3 out of 5 stars review

chlorine seems weaker since 2020

Since the chlorine shortage following 2020, the Sams chlorine we purchase seems to be significantly weaker. My wife and I have been perplexed. We have been using this chlorine for a decade and something seemed to change as we are constantly dealing with low pool chlorine levels now with accompanying cloudy water. It's still cheaper than other options, but I feel the product is no longer as good. Admittedly, I haven't scrutinized the chemical composition, which would likely settle this matter quickly, but I would want to compare/contrast the chlorine before and after 2020.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
May 16, 2023
RedFishBlueFish
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Great for Fresh and Saltwater Pools

I respectfully disagree with Gulf Coast Pool Guy. This chlorine, and all chlorines, can be used in both fresh and saltwater pools. Dichlor IS NOT just for saltwater. You should maintain chlorine at 1 - 5 ppm. Second, if you have a saltwater pool, the purpose is that you typically don't need to add chlorine because it's generated at the electrode. If you can not maintain proper chlorine levels in a salt pool, first look at electrode issues and or salt levels.. You may also use ANY CHLORINE to shock the pool or if excessive use can't keep up the proper chlorine levels. I personally use Trichlor 3 inch tabs in an auto chlorinator, and Dichlor to shock the pool…..and it's a freshwater pool.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Aug 13, 2015
CheMl
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

The Worst Chlorine Ever!

We have always had an in-ground pool and never ran into a problem with bad chlorine. This has made our summer a nightmare trying to keep this pool chlorinated. Our son has also gone through two 50 lbs. and fought his pool all summer. What a waste of money and time this pool season. Sam's used to carry a good product. Very disappointed on this product.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Apr 12, 2023
Gulf Coast Pool Guy
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Good product if it's used for what it was designed

Pool guy here. This product contains Sodium Dichloro-s-Triazinetrione which is a pool sanitizer that releases chlorine into your pool water for the purpose of killing bacteria and preventing algae from forming. As the name suggests, Sodium Dichloro-s-Triazinetrione is Sodium based. This product is designed to be used in a SALTWATER pool or spa environment. Something that's important to note - the "available chlorine" found in this product is approximately 55% which is quite low compared to other sanitizers. For instance, Cal-Hypo has an available chlorine content of about 68%. And TriChlor tablets have an available chlorine content of about 90%. As you can see, it's not reasonable to expect the same results from the same volume of these three products. Also worth noting, Cal-hypo is calcium based and is designed to be used in gunite pools. Trichlor is designed to be used in freshwater and saltwater pools - and pools having vinyl and gunite surfaces. Also, Sodium Dichlor and Trichlor both contain CYA or cyanuric acid which acts as a stabilizer or conditioner that protects the chlorine from being burned off by the sun. This is a very important feature to know about. Without CYA in your pool water, most of your chlorine will disappear in a day or less. On the downside, CYA accumulates in a pool over time as more sanitizer is added. When the CYA level gets above a certain limit, the chlorine in your pool is rendered ineffective no matter how much chlorine you've added. The only way to reduce the amount of CYA is by partially draining and refilling the pool with fresh water. Please understand, there are many different physical and chemical aspects involved in keeping your pool water clean, clear and safe. Anyone can "shock" their pool. But it takes an understanding of your entire pool environment to effectively treat and maintain your pool safely and economically. Just as important as balancing your pool water chemistry is to ensure your pool water circulation and filtration systems are setup and working correctly. You can have a pool whose water is perfectly balanced (free chlorine, combined chlorine, pH, total alkalinity, cyanuric acid, calcium, etc) are all within spec. But if your pump isn't circulating your pool water properly, your pool will in all likelihood turn green in a matter of days. The same is true for having an ineffective filtration system. If you pool filter hasn't been properly serviced, your filter will get jammed up with bacteria that will contaminate your perfectly balanced and circulating pool water. If you find yourself in a situation of not knowing what you should do, I suggest calling a good pool guy in your area. Ask your neighbors who to call - or who NOT to call! And have him or her come out to help get your pool squared away. And with time, you can start taking over the maintenance and management of your own pool should you decide to do so. My two cents!

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
May 6, 2015
UncleSam46
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Spend more for quality

I usually don't deviate from my original brand, but 50lbs for the price that Sam's was offering, was hard to pass up without giving it a try. So I had my water tested and my pool required 12-15 lbs of chlorine granules (shock). I put in the recommended higher dose of 15 lbs. Two days later I had my water retested and the test recommended another 10 lbs of shock. So I added about 12 lbs to be sure - and my water has yet to show progress after yet another 3 days. All other opening methods of back-washing daily and brushing have been included. There is no algae or debris in the pool as I have the filter and a robot constantly running. I don't know if chlorine expires, but the bucket I bought seems to lack potency. Reconsider!

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Jun 29, 2021
LJZ
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great value

There was a lot of price gouging going on right now because of a perceived shortage of chlorine tablets… Nice to know that Sam's Club is not participating and taking advantage. Not only is this a good value each individual tablet is individually wrapped which keeps the chlorine fumes at an absolute minimum until you're ready to use the tablet.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778
Sep 4, 2022
Tom
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

What Changed?

I have been using this product since we installed our pool in 2009. I would use 50lbs a year. I have gone through 50lbs in 5 months. Only thing I can figure is the available chlorine has been lowered to save cost. I understand that the cost is out of Sam's control.

Helpful?5FTKOMP4ODO713879914778