This is EXACTLY the same as the previous version. No idea why people are complaining. I was prepared to totally dislike it but was proven wrong! Still great ice cream at a great price.......and I was never a fan of vanilla till I had Sam's version!

I really wanted to love this ice cream considering Sam’s discontinued their Members Mark Supreme which was by far the best vanilla ice cream we had ever had. This is just vanilla ice cream. Nothing special. Disappointed

Has high fructose corn syrup as a major ingredient. That put me off without looking at anything else. I wish they kept stocking the big box of Breyer's, which was good ingredients.

If your looking for real vanilla ice cream don't get this one. Its vanilla "Flavored." It seems more like an ice milk. It's edible, but not the best.

This isn't going to be confused as a super-premium vanilla. But it's still pretty good, and a great value for the price. It's a little sweeter than most vanillas, so be aware if that is something that would bother you. Most people in my household think it taste like cotton candy.

Lots of haters here?!?! it’s just an affordable ice cream people... if you got the time to complain then go buy fancy ice cream at Whole-foods, etc. it’s good enough for the price. Taste like ice cream and doesn’t taste like card board. I know you can find better ice cream but for the price and quantity I am happy with it ....

This is really good ice cream and we purchase both the Cookies and Cream & the Vanilla every month when we make our monthly trip to Sam's club. However, last month they only had 1 tub of Vanilla ice cream (I did purchase it) and this month no ice cream. I am disappointed that our local Sam's Club as well as the one and hour away does not have it in stock. What happened? Bring back the Member's Mark ice cream.

What made you take a great tasting vanilla ice cream and totally ruin it? I used to eat spoonful's of the vanilla ice cream before adding the toppings. Ewe yuck. Now I add toppings to hide the taste of the ice cream! Can't bring myself to trash it, but I won't buy again unless you change it back to the great tasting ice cream it was before.

The Members Mark ice cream in the white container was much better than this formula. This tastes like there are ice crystals in it while the old formula was very creamy, rich, and very good. I hope that Sams Club will revert to their previous ice cream. Otherwise, I will have to get ice cream elsewhere.

This product (along with tons of other processed dairy products in this country) contains carrageenan. Carrageenan is made from seaweed and has been linked to colon cancer. Sams Club and other US food producers will continue to sell us harmful "foods" until we dictate differently with our buying decisions. I'd encourage everyone to avoid this ice cream and look for products that don't contain carcinogenic additives that will lead you to an early grave.