not sweet enough. ok for kids like for a birthday party or to eat with a sweet cake or pie, but not good for adult who just craves sweet ice cream.

Very creamy tasty ice cream and a great value for the money. I do wish it came in different flavors.

Fructose corn syrup fake vanilla look at the crap on the ingredients it's horrible it's not real ice cream

My absolute favorite ice cream. Keeping trying others and come back to this classic. The taste is just so creamy and delicious!

What happened to Member's Mark Super Premium Vanilla ice cream? Did this replace it? We used to buy it all the time - it was one of our family's favorite vanilla ice creams. Hopefully Sam's Club will bring it back again!

Not rich or creamy at all. As it melts, it is a very thin liquid. This is inexpensive and will feed a lot of people but don’t think your getting a high quality ice cream.

The vanilla pail is good for making flavored shakes or frozen mixed drinks. It's not a premium ice cream; although, the cookies and cream flavor is delicious.

First and last time I tried it since you changed your formula and bucket. It was so soft that I thought my freezer must be going out. Grabed the thermometer and put it in the freezer.... still 0 degrees. Freezer good....ice cream bad!

It's an okay ice cream, nothing like Prairie Farms though, so if you're expecting that kind of taste, you'll be disappointed. Leaves an aftertaste in my mouth, too much artificial flavoring.

For the price the ice cream is okay but it's not great quality. Loaded with corn syrup and artificial flavors. It tastes artificial. Don't really recommend unless you just want something cheap.