Customer reviews for Member's Mark Chicken Salad, 2 lbs. forMember's Mark Chicken Salad, 2 lbs.
Most helpful positive review
1 customer found this helpful
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
ONLY 2ND TO SAM'S ROTISSERIE CHICKEN SALAD
Dewit1200
Most helpful negative review
2 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Chicken salad.
Lisa
8,259 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 5 out of 5 stars review11/19/2022Delicious! I wish this were at my store more often (Sacramento). I buy this every time I visit another store and it is in stock. My store has other brands that tend to be sweeter with the cranberries and nuts. I wish this brand were a staple at my store.
I love this chicken salad!
breez - 5 out of 5 stars review2/6/2025I bought this and was pleasantly surprised by the taste and the ingredients make this product not too bad at all. I am a new fan. The salt content is below 400 and no trans fat. I love the extra celery in this. Kroger had a similar product with a lot of celery but also had too much salt in it. Sams Club offers the same taste but with less salt. Didn't think that was possible. New fan.
Taste Great!
KeishonMember's Mark TeamWe're thrilled you are a fan of the chicken salad, Keishon! Thank you for excellent rating and review! - 1 out of 5 stars review9/15/2021I’m so sorry but this chicken salad isn’t not good. It’s like only chicken, celery and Mayo. Very thick and zero flavor. I bought this to try and see if it would be an option for a simple meal for my boyfriends mom. NO!!! My chicken salad is much better and has flavor. This needs help seriously!!
Not a favorite
Prinboo477 - 1 out of 5 stars review1/2/2018Bought on 12/21/17 two family members became sick. The one who ate more became very ill for days. We will not purchase again. We have made efforts to contact Sam’s and am awaiting a call back. My niece happened to over hear someone else complaining about becoming ill also from chicken salad from Sam’s. We realized then that that was the culprit.
Food poisoning
Pboone - 5 out of 5 stars review3/30/2024We love this the most out of all the chicken salads but it has not been in stock in any of the Arizona stores for months now since the cranberry pecan one came out :( We don't really like the other one and only bought this one. Super sad. Has it been discontinued?
Missing this chicken salad in Arizona </3
FeliciaMember's Mark TeamWe are so glad you like our chicken salad and we are sorry that it has been out of stock, Felicia. It has not been discontinu... - 2 out of 5 stars review7/31/2021Until recently I agreed with the better reviews. However I can't say that anymore. I have been buying the chicken salad for several months but not anymore unless it improves. The last two I purchased, which I also threw away, didn't have the same great taste as before and it's overly chunky. Hope it gets better again.
What Happened
Mimi - 5 out of 5 stars review12/22/2016Sycamore Farms Chicken Salad is awesome! It tastes almost home made. It has large chunks of chicken in it, not like what you buy in the grocery store that is kind of like minced chicken. I love it and buy it often. My favorite way to eat it is on toast. If you love home made chicken salad then give this a try.
Almost Home Made
Liz - 2 out of 5 stars review9/5/2024The last few months the quality has definitely changed. I've bought this for years and the texture and quality of the chicken used to be wonderful! Now it's thick and gristly in some bits clearly using cheaper cuts as well as increasing the amount of celery and the size of the pieces. Some bites were mostly celery this time! I won't be buying it again.
Quality had gone way down
No Wool Over My EyesMember's Mark TeamWe're sorry you didn't enjoy the chicken salad and want you to know all Member's Mark items can be returned for a full refund... - 5 out of 5 stars review6/24/2019I'm pretty picky. And this Chicken salad is great. I pray sams never quits selling it. I will be devistated. It is exactly enough to fill the box of 20 small size croissants that sams sells in the bakery. Makes a perfect chicken salad croissant to take to funerals and gatherings. Just fill them and put them back in the plastic croissant container and go. Taste is great.
Really great can't stop eating it.
Livenlearn - 3 out of 5 stars review3/24/2016This chicken salad has a good taste but the very large chunks of chicken in the recipe ruin the texture of it. It would be excellent if the chicken was shredded or in smaller more blended chunks. I wish the company would fix this because otherwise it is good.
Chicken chunks are too large and hard to chew
Mom2shop - 5 out of 5 stars review5/12/2021So glad to see this back(even under the Members Mark name). Has always been my favorite chicken salad. One reason I go to Sam's Club is to get this. Now they need to bring back the Raspberry Chipotle dip and the ORIGINAL spinach artichoke dip they carried
My favorite Chicken Salad
MrsMac - 5 out of 5 stars review11/14/2016We really enjoy this product, even my husband who ordinarily isn't a big fan of chicken salad. I like that the chicken is chunky and also enjoy that some of the other ingredients are distinguishable as well. Most commercial salads taste like something processed through a blender.
Not the Same As Every Other Chicken Salad
KentuckyLady - 5 out of 5 stars review7/24/2015Until I tried this product I thought chicken salad was an okay sort of thing to have. This one though blew all the others around away. I love it as do others in my family. I particularly like to have it in the Taco Boats (sort tortillas) by Ole El Paso; both the regular size and the mini. It is also great with bread or croissants. This is one product I buy fairly often.
The best chicken salad around
Emeraldisle - 1 out of 5 stars review12/14/2019Purchased this Chicken salad in hope of being the same as they use to carry, found this to be Very bland,unpleasant smell and not very tasty at all.I found to be loaded with more filler ingredients (celery......) and to much liquid for our taste. I will not purchase this product in the future.
Very bland and not a pleasant smell
Hite08 - 1 out of 5 stars review9/18/2024We've purchased this three times now, hoping that each previous experience was a fluke. Unfortunately, every batch is a bad batch. It's gray. The flavor is non-existent. There are chunks of chicken bone and cartilage. It smells funky. Don't waste your money.
Do Not Buy
AJMember's Mark TeamWe're sorry for this experience with our chicken salad, AJ. Please contact Member Support at (888) 301-0332 and we'll do our ... - 3 out of 5 stars review7/31/2018I really wanted to try the chicken salad and brought it home excited. Opened it and went to go start with a spoon and it was molded. Double checked the day it was within its date but still molded and it wasn't loaded on top so we couldn't tell it wasn't until I started that we could tell it was molded so just be careful.
DOUBLE CHECK
MomOnTheGo - 5 out of 5 stars review8/25/2018I'm not a chicken salad person. Normally don't eat it but they were giving away samples, I was very surprised at how good it tasted so I bought it. SInce it's just me I did take some to work and paired it with club crackers just like they had them at Sam's Club. I was still good at home! If you have a potluck to go to, buy this and pretend you made it!!
Pleasantly surprised,
Sheronep - 4 out of 5 stars review1/18/2025When some reviews said TOO much onion...too much pickle... i was like ob YUMMY! I thought it was going to be a savory chicken salad like chicken salad chicks dixie chick. This must have been made with sweet pickles bc its like every other generic chicken salad that tastes like miracle whip ans chunky chicken. I added onion powder pepper and some chives and it was yummy eating with lettuce. I think i lioed the cranberry one better to be honest but...preference and i wont take away a star for that lol
Expecting...chicken salad chik...
not the best but goodMember's Mark TeamWe appreciate your feedback and great rating! - 5 out of 5 stars review9/24/2016I have bought this chicken salad before and have always enjoyed it. This time I bought it for a luncheon and had nothing but rave reviews. Everyone I spoke to wanted to know if it was homemade. I had to confess it was bought at Sam's Club. We made Chicken Salad Croissants and I would make them again. Very pleased!!
Love this product!!
Sam - 2 out of 5 stars review12/10/2019After MembersMark replaced the original vendor there are problems. Few month ago it was recalled as unsafe to eat. My last purchased on 12-4-2019 had the same expiration date which I did not check when purchased, but after eating part of it few days later it tasted bad.
MembersMark not good as original Vender
Moka