Disappointed 2nd time on my online/pickup order... first time the apples were not crisp anymore (old), today I got old & 2 rotten apples. =(

Well, if they were not rotten, they are great. Sadly, half the bag was mush before I tried to eat them.

These honeycrisp apples are delicious, crisp, and fresh while in season, as they are locally grown. Off season, they taste like dirt. Also, they are soft, rotting, and bruised. Not worth the money. I don't recommend.

We quite often buy apples at Sam’s club. Unfortunately this particular bag was not that great. There were a lot of brown spots and the apples were not sweet and crisp and they usually are.

Most times I've had honey crisp have been steeply discounted older bruised ones. Every one of those was superior to these. Very disapointed. Remembering back usually disappointed in their fruits

I have been buying these apples for several years. The last few bags have all had at least 1-2 apples that were already soft and rotten. You can cut around that, but lose half an apple. Love these apples, but not sure they are worth the price if we can’t eat them.

I was extremely disappointed when I ordered Honeycrisp Apples online for curbside pickup. First, there was a smell of a chemical that reminded me of some sort of paint thinner. Could not for the life of me find what was making that smell until I got into my house and was putting my order away but before I realized they were the apples, my child and her friend had taken 2 washed them up and started to eat them. I was putting the apples away when I found the apples to have that chemical smell to them. I made the kids to throw them away. When I took the rest of the apples out of the bag I also found every apple had numerous mushy spots and that same chemical smell, so I just decided to get rid of all of them. I am very disappointed and concerned why they smelled of harsh chemicals!

Bought these and two days later decided to remove from the bag and put them all in the refrigerator and found that half of the bag contained rotten apples. I have never in my life bought rotten apples from a grocery store, but leave it to Sam’s Club to make that possible. This was one of three items from one shopping trip that were rotten within a couple days of purchasing. I was on the fence about renewing my membership, and this kind of quality is definitely pushing me to the NO WAY side.

I love these apples! I buys 6 bags a week. They have been inconsistent in taste, texture and size as they usually are and as compared to other types of apples...perhaps that comes with a hybrid apple. At the moment the price has been in the $4 per bag rang because as I mentioned the inconsistency...usually they are nearly $10 a bag!!! I feel the club needs to loose a star for that itself.

I have ordered these numerous times and normally have good results. Not this time. I couple of the apples had large holes in the peeling. Browned and unedible. I notified customer service and was told I'd receive a e-coupon to make up for it within 48 hours. It has been a week and I don't have it yet.