I know apple pie and this is a very good apple pie. The crust is flaky, the spicing well done and apples well cooked. It compares favorably to the best apple pie in the world, i.e. my wife's. In fact she quit baking because these are so good she figures "why bother?"

Not fully cooked. I got this on curbside pickup for my child's birthday, but it was not fully cooked. Parts of the top looked and felt like raw dough. The bottom and the underside of the crust top also were not fully cooked, but the top was burnt in a few spots. It looked like it was cooked at too high of a temperature since some was burnt and other parts were raw. Very disappointed birthday since it was too late to go out and get something else.

I have purchased the Sam's Club 12" apple pies for years and they have always been great. Now that they came out with a Honeycrisp Apple Pie - it is just one of the best out there! The apples in the pie taste fresh and have that wonderful Honeycrisp Apple sweetness and flavor. The crust is nice and compliments the filling well. I hope they keep this version in stock all year!!!

Too much pastry, not enough apple filling.

Couldn’t wait to eat. Received out of packaging and in parts

poor quality...undercooked dough...wayyy too much dough

Delicious pie and at a fantastic price

Not as good as they were in the past, soggy crust! Yuk

Says award winning. Had very little flavor at all. Maybe I just got a bad one

The crust on this pie is too soft. If the crust was more crispy this would be a great pie. The filling is very good.