Was so excited to try this apple pie. I was so disappointed. The crust was soggy, the filling had little to no cinnamon or spice, it had far too much sugar and just a disappointment with the first bite. It had plenty of apple pieces but was very lacking in any type of flavor. Surprised that this pie has won awards. I’ve been making apple pies for 60 years and I’ll put mine in a contest over this one any day and win. I could give their bakers a few pointers in making a flavorful pie with a good crust. Pie was fed to the chickens.

OMG!!! This pie was so good. We heated it up in the oven and cut into it and put ice cream on top. We were all in heaven. The apple slices inside were nice and big, the crust, (which is my favorite part) was so good. I have gotten this pie before which is why I came back for it again. I think they have this item all year around. Which is awesome.

I've never purchased an apple pie in my life. It happens to be my husbands favorite and has always been homemade or nothing in our house. I was in Sam's preparing for a friends visit and was looking for a dessert. As both men liked apple pie, I decided to pick one up and give it a try. It was a huge hit! The honeycrisp apples were delicious as was the crust. I rarely eat apple pie and... I loved it. I would definately buy it again.

We always buy your pies. The last one we bought was not baked all the way. The bottom crust was mush the whole pie was nasty. Don't know what happened but won't buy one for a while. We always Loved the pies until this happened glad it was only for us and not company. Would have been totally upset worse.

I have purchased the Sam's Club 12" apple pies for years and they have always been great. Now that they came out with a Honeycrisp Apple Pie - it is just one of the best out there! The apples in the pie taste fresh and have that wonderful Honeycrisp Apple sweetness and flavor. The crust is nice and compliments the filling well. I hope they keep this version in stock all year!!!

The apple pies are usually awesome but this one had apple seeds and a few core pieces in it. We buy the apple pie a lot but never had one with this issue. Not sure if it is a new machine that is cleaning the apples . The taste was still good but having to pick out the apple parts was frustrating. Hopefully the next pie we buy will not have this same issue

Bought 2-3 days before holiday. When came time to eat, pie was full of mold.

This pie is apparently award-winning and I believe that. It's good every time I buy it. I love it with vanilla bean ice cream to top.

This pie is designed to feed 16. We enjoy waming it in the oven and serving it ala mode with good vanilla icecream.plenty of apple and all the right spices.

The pie was tasty but cutting slices was not the best experience. The filling would flow out and create a messy look. The filling was on the sweeter side too when I expected some tart taste.