Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Prime Rib, priced per pound for
Member's Mark Prime Rib, priced per pound
4.3 out of 5 stars
stars631 ratings271 reviews
  1. 5 stars68% (429)
  2. 4 stars11% (69)
  3. 3 stars7% (45)
  4. 2 stars6% (40)
  5. 1 star8% (48)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 91-100 of 271 reviews
Nov 23, 2025
HickoryRoaster
5 out of 5 stars review

Delicious - great flavor and cooked perfectly

I bought one of these last year, not paying attention to the label and didn't know it was pre-cooked. I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and taste. Quite frankly, it had more flavor than my from-scratch prime rib roasts - without all the work. I'd recommend this for people that want a great tasting roast and don't have the several hours to roast one from scratch.

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 7, 2025
JOANN
5 out of 5 stars review

Fully cooked prime rib

delish, we sliced the cold prime rib into thin slices and cut out the fat, then dipped into boiling beef broth, or a packet of lipton au jus to warm it up, then place on toasted rolls with horseradish sour cream dressing , fresh cut fries and a beer.

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 7, 2025
KATHARINE
1 out of 5 stars review

Tasted like corned beef, no Au jus, don't waste your money! How in the WORLD they managed to make a Prime Rib taste like old corned beef is beyond me, but there REALLY needs to be a review of their seasonings for PRIME RIB. By someone with GOOD taste buds, who knows and understands WHAT a good juicy Prime Rib should taste like to begin with, would be a good start. Paid WAAAAAAY too much for this and ruined Sunday dinner.

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 24, 2025
NORMAN
5 out of 5 stars review

Easy and delicious

This was really good. Heating takes longer than the directions. i use a meat thermometer to get the middle to medium rare. Quality was very good with nice marbeling. I made a great au jus and horseradish dipppinh sauce. It's easy to season. I cut a few steaks and will blacken them. I see Walmart has a similar product incase Sam's is not in stock

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Nov 21, 2022
Besos78
5 out of 5 stars review

Best Ever

This is one if the best out there. I know I need to make one of my own but when you have a big family and busy cooking everything for Thanksgiving this helps me and save time. I look forward to warming this up every year and soak up the compliments. Delicious!!!

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 30, 2017
myork
5 out of 5 stars review

Prime Rib fully cooked

Bought one of these for Christmas dinner and it was delicious. I didn't follow the reheating directions though as I didn't want it further cooked or dried out. I reheated in the microwave four 1 1/4" slices and served with the au jus. Leftovers were served the same way. Delicious, moist, tender and very pink! Pricey but will do it again next Christmas!!

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Nov 26, 2022
Maggie
5 out of 5 stars review

Excellent Taste & Easy to Make

I purchased this along with a ham and a turkey breast for Thanksgiving. This prime rib was such a hit with my family. It was already cooked, so all I had to do was warm it up. I purchased an electric meat thermometer (like you see on some grills) which allowed me to monitor the temperature without opening the oven. Easy to make and delicious to eat. I would definitely purchase this again.

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 12, 2024
SUZANNE
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Prime Rib Mishap

I had to order it on one day and not be able to pick it up until the next day. I was charged one price but when I went to pick up the 2 prime ribs, they didn't total up to that amount though my account was charged differently. It took a couple days for the correction to be made on your end but the stress was something I didn't need at the time. I have to travel 65 miles each way to get to the Sam's Club and then to find I'm not getting what I paid for wasn't what I drove for. But again, you finally corrected the amount on my account so I'm happy about that. Would have liked the 2 prime ribs would have been closer in size than they were. One was very small compared to the other one.

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 29, 2018
ScoutCR
5 out of 5 stars review

Best Prime Rib for Make at Home Holiday Meal

I purchased this for our family Christmas dinner for 25 people. I bought (2) 5.5 lb pieces and tried to match them up in the store so they would look like the same roast. I followed the instructions to the letter and also checked the temperature at every 45-50 minutes. As soon as they hit 120 degrees on the inside of the roast I set them out for 20 minutes. The result was perfectly roasted prime rib. Everyone raved about the flavor and how they came out perfectly. I did roast them in an electric roasting pan as my oven was tied up ,making a spiral ham other than that I just did what the directions said to do. Thank you Member's Mark and Sams Club for making my first Prime Rib a winner!

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835
Dec 12, 2024
Ann
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible, don’t buy!

Purchased this a couple of days ago for a special occasion meal. It was absolutely terrible. It tasted very processed, not like any kind of roast beef weve ever eaten. Complete waste of a lot of money, we didn’t eat what we had put on our plates and threw the rest away. I was really looking forward to serving and eating it based on all the positive reviews, can’t believe anyone would ever purchase it more than once. So very disappointed ☹️ would give it less than one star if possible

Helpful?3DEP6TM7MTB913731814835