Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Yellow Peaches, 4 lbs. for
Yellow Peaches, 4 lbs.

Member photos

  • +23 images
Sort by |
Showing 421-430 of 1,473 reviews
Jul 18, 2025
Lee76
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Don't buy.

These were rotten. Picked them up car side. I can't believe they allowed these peaches to be pushed upon their customers. I sent pics and received a refund.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Aug 21, 2024
Southern Belle
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Enjoy peaches!

I enjoy having a fruit smoothie for breakfast. These usually taste great. Sometimes they will be more tart than I like but mixing with other fruits doesn't cause my smoothie to have a bitter taste. Sometimes they are too ripe so I will need to cut them up & put in freezer bags. Making a smoothie with frozen fruit is not an issue. Most of the time they will last in the refrigerator for a week but if they are ripening too quickly I will freeze them.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Aug 16, 2024
BingBang
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Not great

Usually love HMC Farms peaches. We lived in CA for 15 years and the peaches there were the just the best. We have bought other boxes of HMC Farms peaches that were wonderful. It all depends on the varietal. These were called Sierra Rich, which I had never heard of, but took a chance. They were terrible! Many already browning inside, they clung to the stone and the flavor was a real disappointment. If you buy HMC, I would avoid this variety of peach.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Jul 8, 2024
Andrew G
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Don't Judge These Peaches by Their Smell!

While my peaches smelled delightful, their taste was anything but sweet! It’s rare when I’m disappointed with the produce from Sam’s Club, but this purchase was certainly one of them. I only wish I had returned these, as I am completely disappointed.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Jul 21, 2024
Patricia
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Don't try to kid the public.We know our stuff.

The nectarines that were in a peach box were fine if I had wanted nectarines. They are good, but don't act quite the same in a peach pie as peaches. Too much juice and shrinkage, so it is too soupy for a good peach pie. Taste is close, so not the problem.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Jul 17, 2021
Regular Customer
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Yellow Peaches

These peaches are excellent, but there's a trick to getting them at their freshest. Every year, when they first come in (in June), the first couple of weeks they're not that good. They're best in July, and in August they tend to get mealy. Stick to buying them only in the sweet spot.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Jul 9, 2024
Sams customer
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Pass on the peaches.

The peaches were terrible. They were firm when we bought them but they smelled good. We tried one as soon as we got them home and it was hard and not sweet. We waited two days to try them again and by that time several were molding. We threw those out and tried one of the remaining ones every day. They never got softer or sweeter. Do not recommend.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Oct 16, 2021
GmaSue
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Hard Peaches

Waited several days to eat the first one. It still was the texture of an apple. Good flavor and juicy but not getting ripe. Then after a few days more they got rubbery. After a week several peaches were moldy. These peaches were rotting from the pit to the outside. Rather strange.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Sep 20, 2024
Ritzeegal
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Loved Them

This was the first batch of yellow peaches I bought and they were excellent. I ate them up real fast and regretted not buying two boxes. I have bought twice since them and neither box matched that first choice. The later purchases were good but not excellent like the first batch.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066
Jul 13, 2024
Marilyn
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Disappointed

I remembered how good Sam’s peaches were last summer and looked forward to seeing them available this season. I bought a box around the first of June and they never ripened. They started to rot before they ripened. I purchased another box last week and they are overripe. They have a pretty good flavor, but they are mushy so they will have to be thrown out before I can finish them.

Helpful?2E2GFYOM7GXS13713871066