Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Nature's Own Butterbread 20 oz. for
Nature's Own Butterbread 20 oz.
4.3 out of 5 stars
stars2,968 ratings2,954 reviews
  1. 5 stars72% (2,124)
  2. 4 stars8% (233)
  3. 3 stars6% (168)
  4. 2 stars4% (128)
  5. 1 star11% (315)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 2,281-2,290 of 2,954 reviews
Jun 27, 2025
Clint
5 out of 5 stars review

best bread on the market. stays fresher longer than any other bread I've used. Lasts longer than any other.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
May 11, 2023
bev49
4 out of 5 stars review

Improvement

I wrote a review weeks ago about my disappointment in the quality of the Nature's Own Butterbread. The bread had become dry and no longer soft. In the past the bread was so soft and fresh and would stay that way until the loaf was eaten. I stated that it seemed to maybe be overcooked. I had used it for years and was disappointed that I was having to look for a replacement and by the way I couldn't find one that compared to the former loaves. I have noticed that the last five or six loaves I have purchased have improved. The bread is softer and less dry. The color is no longer the dark brown it had gotten to be. I appreciate the improvement. Keep it up!

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
Mar 1, 2023
BRN
2 out of 5 stars review

Not the same. It’s changed

I’ve been buying this bread for years and I. The last few months. It’s like the bread has been frozen and thawed. It has lost it most delicious squish melt in your mouth bread. Very very disappointing. Just was hoping the first few times they were old loaves. Not the case. Please go back to the old way.

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
reply from Brand Team

We appreciate you contacting us about your recent experience with our Nature's Own bread and we’re sorry you were disappointed. Quality is one of our top priorities and we have high quality standards, so when something we bake does not meet a consumer's expectations, we take it seriously. Please visit https://www.naturesownbread.com/contact and correspond based on your product quality.

Feb 16, 2023
Sue1949
1 out of 5 stars review

My favorite bread has changed for the worse!

This use to be the only bread I bought, but the last several loaves I have noticed that the quality and size has gone down AND the price has increased. I always check the date when buying my bread and the freshness of this particular bread has always been great for up to and beyond 10 days. Now, the loaves have bought over the last 6 weeks have dried out quickly and are a fraction of the once luscious size sandwich bread. I will not be buying this again, I'll go back to one of the more dependable brands for quality and size. I could have understood the raising of price during this inflation, but raising the price and cutting size and quality - shame on you!!!!

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
Jan 14, 2022
bbailey81
5 out of 5 stars review

A Comercially-Baked Bread That Tastes and Feels Like Artisan

I bought a loaf of Nature's Own Butterbread instead of my artisan-style pricey loaf and, boy was I surprised! The slices were moist, flavorful, and had the mouthfeel, not unlike the more expensive artsy breads. It's my family's new favorite, whether eating it as breakfast toast or on a lunchtime sandwich creation.

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
Dec 8, 2024
Granny
3 out of 5 stars review

Changed

I used to buy this bread all the time. It was great. Best tasting bread around. But a couple years back or so they have had to change something or someway that the bread is produced. It feel soft to the touch in the grocery store when you gently squeeze the Loaf but when you get it home and pull some of the bread out it has a stale crust like feeling / texture to the bread even though it is soft to the squeeze touch. Please return to a previous procedure so that the bread does not have this dry crust like texture.

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
reply from Nature's Own

We appreciate you contacting us about your experience with our Nature's Own bread and we’re sorry you were disappointed. Quality is one of our top priorities and we have high quality standards, so when something we bake does not meet a consumer's expectations, we take it seriously. Please visit https://www.naturesownbread.com/contact and correspond based on your product quality.

Mar 29, 2025
JeeBee
1 out of 5 stars review

Not my butterbread anymore

Shocked at the obvious changes made in recipe from original taste and texture. I cannot eat another bite. So seriously sad and disappointed. A loaf of garbage; as if I were eating styrofoam compared to the heavenly bread it used to be. No one will continue buying this if it isn't reversed to the former recipe. All the once great foods are disappearing over time, including Butterbread. You were once the best!

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
reply from Nature's Own

We appreciate you contacting us about your experience with our Nature's Own bread and we’re sorry you were disappointed. Quality is one of our top priorities and we have high quality standards, so when something we bake does not meet a consumer's expectations, we take it seriously. Please visit https://www.naturesownbread.com/contact and correspond based on your product quality.

Aug 30, 2022
Anonymous
3 out of 5 stars review

Inconsistent quality

The last two loaves of the Nature’s own butternut bread has been very dry and coarse, not at all soft lime it usually is. I have noticed this with this bread from time to time- not consistently good. Will be shopping around for a better bread if they can’t improve on the quality at all times.

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
Nov 1, 2024
Twin49
1 out of 5 stars review

Dry bread

What happened to our Butter bread ? All of a sudden it is dry ,coarse and dark crust . Smells funny when I open the bag. I love the butter bread and last two weeks when I bought it has been toast dry . Very costly to not be good . It will usually stay fresh for three weeks .

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
reply from Nature's Own

We appreciate you contacting us about your experience with our Nature's Own bread and we’re sorry you were disappointed. Quality is one of our top priorities and we have high quality standards, so when something we bake does not meet a consumer's expectations, we take it seriously. Please visit https://www.naturesownbread.com/contact and correspond based on your product quality.

Mar 2, 2024
DisneyMama39
2 out of 5 stars review

So disappointed in how this bread has changed! :(

Nature’s Own Butterbread used to be the perfect white bread. It was the softest bread you could get, the quality was awesome. In literally recommended it to people. WHAT HAPPENED?! Now, every loaf we buy is dry and hard and we are tired of wasting our money on making sandwiches we hate now because the bread always tastes stale. We have been loyal to the brand but we are fed up. FIX IT or everyone is going to give up on Nature’s Own. Same goes for the honey wheat!

Review from naturesownbread
Helpful?3O4JPP7E69FD13672163887
reply from Nature's Own

We appreciate you contacting us about your experience with our Nature's Own bread and we’re sorry you were disappointed. Quality is one of our top priorities and we have high quality standards, so when something we bake does not meet a consumer's expectations, we take it seriously. Please visit https://www.naturesownbread.com/contact and correspond based on your product quality.