It was delicious! Not overly sweet.

Cute, but did not taste that great.

So beautiful to look at but the taste was definitely lacking. The buttercream filling was tasteless and there was barely enough chocolate buttercream around the outside to taste. Gorgeous and impressive looking but just didn’t hit the spot for me in the taste-department. I would have preferred a Little Debbie Swiss cake roll over this.

The Yule Log was great. It was a beautiful work of art. It tasted great and Sam’s Club was one of the only places that carried a Yule Log.

Cake inside was delicious, the outside was like taking a bite into eating thick waxy chocolate with an odd taste to it

Sam's really knocked it out of the park with this one! This was an absolute hit for our office Christmas party! The texture was amazing, wasn't too dry or too moist. Great value as well. Don't skip on this item if you have a party coming up or want to buy it for the family!

horrible, as a firm supporter of the pumpkin roll I had high hopes for this but was sadly disappointed. it was chocolate cake with whipped cream in the middle, there qas no buttercream at all. just move alo g right passed this when you aee it i. the store

This cake is beautiful to look at, but the taste is lacking. The frosting in the center of the cake is very very bland. The cake itself is very good, but the frosting in the center ruins it. Just a little sweeting or flavor would make a huge difference. I cannot recommend this. We love Sam's cakes and the family was excited to try this, but it fell short. I gave it 3 stars mostly because of the presentation.

Not at all as pictured. I was expecting something that was presentable for our Christmas table. Instead I got a dusted log. No lovely icing at all. I was in the store 2 days ago and saw them beautifully decorated and ordered one to picked up on Christmas Eve. I am terribly disappointed that I have to go home, make icing, and decorate it myself.

The description here and the label on the cake itself say that it has chocolate and vanilla buttercream. It says on the label that it's filled with buttercream. As the title says, that is a straight up lie. The inside is whipped cream, which I loathe. The cake is good, the exterior frosting is good, but the inside is gross. I would not have purchased this had I known.