Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Organic Boneless and Skinless Chicken Breasts, priced per pound for
Member's Mark Organic Boneless and Skinless Chicken Breasts, priced per pound

Customer photos

Sort by |
Showing 381-390 of 470 reviews
Jan 7, 2026
Ann
1 out of 5 stars review

Unsealed packaging. Bad before cook/freeze by date

Chicken came with a padding inside of the sealed bag, so you cannot freeze it in the same sealed packaging, you will still need to separate it before freezing. The packaging on mine was not actually sealed and leaked out juices in my fridge. When I came around to separating it to freeze it smelled bad and slimy. Had to throw away $25.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Nov 21, 2025
Mimi
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible Texture

I tried to give this chicken a chance on 3 separate occasions but every batch has been tough and almost woody in texture. I made a casserole using this chicken for a sick friend and now I'm embarrassed because it was so tough. The prior brand they carried was far more superior. It was worth the extra cost and the 80 minute round trip drive. I don't even want to feed this “chicken” to my dog. And the price per pound is ridiculously high.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Dec 4, 2025
STEVE
1 out of 5 stars review

Not Worth the price!

Not at all like the previous Farmers Market chicken they used to sell. This chicken is obviously on steroids! I had to return two purchases within the last month because the chicken was spoiled. They were within 5 days of the expiration date, and I opened them as soon as I got home! They stunk so bad I almost through up!

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Feb 21, 2025
Craig
2 out of 5 stars review

Bring Back the Previous Brand

This brand of organic chicken breast is new to my store. The chicken is tough and the individual “pockets “ contain widely different sizes of breasts making it difficult to bake a batch cooked evenly. Bring back the previous brand. I’m currently searching for another source for my use.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Apr 21, 2025
Tee
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back George Farms

We got our membership because of George farms chicken breast! Almost cancelled it this year when I went in and they had replaced them with these "organic" breasts! They are huge ! Which means tough.. And they are alot more expensive. After this years membership expires,I won't renew.. Unless they bring back George Farms. They are still in business.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Dec 22, 2025
Aaron
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back georges farmers market chicken

For years we have had the same chicken offering, georges farmers market. Excellent price, well trimmed, texturely never an issue either. Since the transition - horrible price, less quantity, poorer product. Its been really dissapointing to see a staple just disappear and be replaced with a mediocre product. "Organic" or not. Much prefer the "non organic" but clearly better chicken. The members mark brand name loses value through the meat products. Makes it hard to trust the brand as a whole.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Jan 4, 2026
ROBERT
2 out of 5 stars review

Terrible Chicken

Awful chicken! Never buy again! I wish they would bring back Georges Farmers Market chicken it was the best consistently! This Members Mark is sourced from various "low bidder?, "low quality" farms. You never know what your getting until there is a recall.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Nov 21, 2025
MANDY
3 out of 5 stars review

Not a good replacement product

We are not happy with this chicken compared to the brand it replaced. We've bought a couple times now and it is usually kind of tough, not a consistent size. Not any better than any random package of chicken. We had bought the George's for several years and could count on it being tender and good flavored product. If it's a cost issue I would have rather be able to buy the previous product for a few more dollars.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Nov 21, 2025
CARRIE
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible - Tasteless, Tough, Weird Texture

This chicken is horrible. It is tasteless, tough, and has a weird texture. Sam's Club you need to bring back Georges Farmers Market Chicken. It is very disappointing that you replaced Georges with this Members Mark brand that is considerably more expensive and tastes horrible. If I had been served this at a restaurant I would have sent it back. We won't be buying this again and not sure if we will continue our Sam's Club membership if the quality of products offered keep going downhill. I hope you will reconsider the type of meat that you are putting on shelves.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327
Nov 21, 2025
JENNIFER
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible Texture and Taste - Bring Back George's!

Purchased since George's is no longer available. Very disappointed with the taste and texture. Giant breasts that are tough and grainy like the cheap chicken breasts. Once again Sam's Club has thrown their members under the bus and substituted a great produce with their brand that is more expensive and nothing like the original.

Helpful?30ETHLWJUNY813632405327