Birds love it

Very poor seed. Calcium Carbonate, and a lot of it, is just rock. So much rock made into very tiny pieces. The majority of the bag is the tiny yellow seed that no birds want. There is near nothing for supposed peanuts and raisins. We had lots of birds eating from this feeder for 2 years, bought this bag and now nothing but squirrels shaking it and doves on the ground from time to time. Today we cleaned it out and put in our previous mix, and within a half hour all our birds were back. Save your money and get real seed, not garbage.

I use to love this bird seed but now it is full of filler seed. Very poor quality. Before it had tons of sunflower seeds and big peanuts. Now it has more filler than sunflower seeds. Flakes from the filler go flying when I'm pouring it. Very messy. Wish they'd go back to how it was. I won't be buying this anymore. Sams club messed up changing this feed.

Bought 3 bags of this due to the awesome price. I had full feeders but no birds after the first couple days. Tried to wait it out assuming theyre birds theyll eat it if theyre hungry right? No. They will not. Its been a 2 week battle and i finally broke down and bought the old food. And my birds are back. This seed really does have a odd smell to it. Like old raisins. Or maybe spoiled wine. The sunflower seeds are very small. And honestly the quality wasnt that good. One of the few sams purchases i am disappointed with.

This is a very good blend, but it contains raisins, which are toxic to dogs. If you have a dog, make sure to put the feeder where the dog can't get to it. The birds scatter the seeds and raisins on the ground, and if a dog has access to that area, it will eat the raisins.

I have always purchased Pennington Bird food which has been quite popular with a variety of birds. Typically there are at least 15-30 birds at my 4 feeders throughout the day. The Member's Mark Supreme Blend Wild Bird Food was on sale, so I thought I would try it. Big mistake! All 4 feeders have been untouched for over one week. I even scattered some seed on the ground but even the squirrels aren't eating it!

Hello: I've been buying Valley Splendor Supreme Bird Seed from Sam's Club for several years but am very disappointed with my last two 40-Lb bag purchases, both bought at different times within the last six months. Both were loaded with gypsy moth larvae and adult moths. I've tried to get rid of the larvae by putting the bags out in the hot sun all day, but that didn't do any good. Apparently the tiny eggs are very resistant. I filled my two large Droll Yankee bird feeders with the seed anyway, after picking out as many larvae as I could see, hoping the birds would still eat the seed, but the decaying remains of the eggs, hatched larvae and associated fine webbing messed the bird seed and the feeder up so badly that the birds wouldn't eat the food. I ended up throwing about half of the first bag and all of the second bag away, in addition to having to take my feeders apart and scour them out. I would not recommend this product to anyone. Also, I thought you would want to be made aware of the problem.

Excellent quality value and price.I have already recommended it to my friends at work and will be buying alot of this.I checked it side by side with the other at Sams that went up so much in price and there was no difference ,this may be better because it has lots of fruits too.All the birds in my yard love it.

After reading some of the previous reviews I was leary of buying a 40 pound bag of something that wasn't going to be good. I have used seed before that the birds simply raked out onto the ground. I really liked the Morining Song Songbird Garden and was really disappointed when our Sams stopped carrying it. I hate changing brands after finding one that works so well. I put the Valley Splendor Supreme Blend into my feeders today and watched for results. I have just as many birds as I had before. I have cardinals, doves, lots of various small birds and titmouse. They are not raking it out of the feeder. I am so relieved. I do miss the Morning Song Songbird Garden 5/7 bags. If Sams were to carry it again I would buy it but am frankly pleased with the Valley Splendor Supreme Blend for now and am glad my birds like it so well.

The birds like it!