Liked it but thought it would be more pie like. The pumpkin could be stronger. Overall it was good I was just expecting more pumpkin and hoping it was more pie like.

The cake portion was rather dry and the crumble on top was very hard. It took a very sharp knife to cut a slice. We had two small slices then threw the rest in the trash.

I really wanted to love this cake and the initial flavors did not disappoint. However the cake I brought home was extremely dry... somewhere between stale and just dry. The smell was awesome.

Everything I buy from the Sam's bakery is very tasty. This is a tasteless mess! I was really shocked. It was like eating cardboard. For the price, I expected much better.

What a delightful treat! The crumb is really nice. This is a good combination of moist and sweet. it is not overly sweet and goes perfect with coffee any time of day! My whole family enjoyed this cake.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. This cake was just okay. The cake part was dry and did not have a lot of pumpkin flavor. The crumb topping was a little too crunchy, but had pretty good flavor.

This had so much crumble on top of it that I could barely cut it. It was disgusting. Whole thing along with the pumpkin pie I bought ended up in the trash

Bought this because of a sample in the store, the one I bought was terrible, most of it was streusel and very little pumpkin. What a waste of $12. I ended up throwing 3/4 of it away

CRUMB TOPPING WAS HARD AS A ROCK!!! NEVER NEVER NEVER...DID I MENTION N E V E R AGAIN !!!!!!!!!!!! I CALLED AND COMPLAINED AND RECEIVED A CREDIT - THANK YOU !

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. I thought the overall flavor was fine, but the cake was so dry that I could not even finish a very small piece. The best part was the crumb topping and even that was really dry.