I thought, “Well, the price and ingredients are right, so I may as well give the taste a chance.” But I am so picky and have been drinking another brand for several years. I doubted I would like the new offering, much less hopeful that I would prefer them. BUT I DO! I prefer the Member’s Mark protein shake over my old favorite brand. Delicious! Good job!

The price is right and you receive three more shakes per box, but that's where the similarities end. By my standards, the shakes are not creamy at all. They have the consistency of store bought chocolate milk. The chocolate taste is OK, but it is somewhat strong and a little bitter to me. And as the other reviewers have stated there is a strong after taste I can't really describe it but it's not very pleasant and does taste somewhat like medicine. So will I buy these again? Probably not as they are not typical Members Mark quality.

Shake is very thick

I poured it into a glass and it poured out kind of thick like so I was a little apprehensive about drinking it. It is delicious. It was nice and smooth, no gritty taste. It actually was not really that thick at all. I really liked the taste of it better than one of its competitors. I would definitely buy this product.

Please don't mistake this drink as a substitute for Premier Protein. The taste while drinking is okay, but the aftertaste is blah and chalky. I noticed the price of PP had been increasing so I wasn't surprised Member's Mark came out with their own. Yes, it is cheaper, but you get what you pay for. I won't be purchasing this again.

These protein shakes remind me of a chocolate slim fast. The consistency is not too thick which me and my kids like. It taste more like a chocolate milk than a thick shake. It is very yummy and with 30 g of protein it packs a punch. It’s pretty low in fat, carbohydrates, and sugar. It definitely does not lack in the flavor or vitamin department. I would happily purchase this again.

Although I’m not very familiar with those types of drinks I will say that it didn’t taste terrible & for the most part did mimic chocolate milk. The container itself seemed to hold up quite well & although each container doesn’t have a safety seal the cap is more secure than most drinks so there’s no worries there.

We got these, and my husband was concerned about the taste since they are sugar free. He loves them! They taste great, are quick and easy, and he’s not consuming too much sugar. This is a fantastic meal replacement option! He loves them for breakfast especially.

I enjoy the taste of these protein drinks. This is one that does not spike my blood sugar which is very important to me as others are low carb but spike my blood sugar. These are great for on the go or to take to work. I highly recommend this product.

This shake is priced a little lower (per bottle) than Premier Protein, and about the same as Muscle Milk. It's higher in sodium than either brand, and has a little more fat than Premier. As others have said, the taste is pretty artificial. However, I found that if you drink it cold--and quickly--the taste is not so bad.