I'm a faithful, long-term Premier Protein shake drinker. However, I got these due to Sam's low stock and I read that they were as good. I will say that they're not the same as far as taste or texture but I can use them as an alternative due to supply or financial shortage.

A bit of an after taste

I bought this product 2weeks ago and was excited to try since it looked like the Premiere Protein Shakes I loved. I was disappointed when I found congealed slimy strips in the shake after shaking well. I had only found this before after shakes had set for months on my shelf before use. The second day the congealed strip was about 2 inches long and got caught in my throat. I had to drink water to get it down. This chocolate shake is also more double chocolate than milk chocolate. I decided instead of wasting them I’d put them in glass so I could remove the slime and then add almond milk. It works okay. I won’t buy again.

These are horrible. I've been drinking the Fairlife protein shakes but evidently Sam's is not sticking then anymore. Tried these as an alternative, couldn't even finish one it tasted so bad. Tastes like plastic. Going to try and get my money back, don't waste yours!

Bought these to have as a quick meal supplement in the mornings when I'm busy, I took a drink from one and it was so bitter and nasty! I tried to make it better by adding sweetener to it and that helped for a little bit but today I opened one and tried to drink it and it was CHUNKY! it has already gone bad. I keep them in a mini fridge so they're kept cool like they're supposed to be and despite the fact that they're supposed to still be good till November they're already expired. I paid almost 60 total for two boxes of these and they've completely gone to waste! Wish I could get my money back. 🤬

I tried these do to the rising cost of Premier protein. They were $19.98 for 18 of the members mark brand. Taste a little bit different than Premier, but i could manage with the savings... but Sam's just raised the price higher than Premier protein $22.56 as i write this.. so might as well just go back to buying Premier as the Taste isn't worth Sam's raising the prices.

I used to love this brand because it had a great flavor and consistency as compared to the name brand. About the past year I noticed the liquid is very thick. I honestly thought I was buying just a bad batch or maybe the supplies were in extreme temperatures but every time I would buy them, they still had that thickness with an odd taste.

If you were the kid who ate chalk, you'll love this. I bought this because they were out of my wife's preferred brand for several weeks. I figured, how bad could it be? Chalk. Chocolate chalk. That's what it tasted like. I walk the streets at night trying to make enemies so I have someone to give the rest of this case to.

I bought this as a cheaper alternative to the premier protein shakes. The taste is almost the same but there is 1 vast difference. This makes my hands and feet swell. I'm not sure if I'm sensitive to an ingredient they use or what it is but I started noticing the days I drank this I would swell whereas with premier protein and muscle milk I don't get that reaction.

Too expensive per unit