Apparently my club stopped getting the Atkins Milk Chocolate Shakes, so yesterday I purchased a pack for $26, hoping they would be as good if not better than the Atkins Shakes. I was so disappointed, the flavor was off and it seemed watery at times. Could only get about half of it down and ended up throwing it away. In my opinion, it may be low in carbs but it’s no where near as good as the Atkins brand.

I decided to try the shakes(was using aktins choc) to save money. At first I noticed an after-taste. Didnt think I would like them but they weren't bad c and wanted to drink the remaining 17. By the time I finished I nolonger could detect the strange taste. GO FIGURE. IDK. I found Akins tasted a little better but not enough to go back so I continued with the Sams brand. Bottom line, they're good

I started looking for shakes on the go. I needed shakes were to give me my protein during the liquid stage of my preop and post op during bariatric surgery. I had premier protein before, and was just looking for something similar that didn’t break the bank. I was shopping for some other household items and saw this shake in my search. This is just my opinion but I perfer the thickness of these shakes, there isn’t an overwhelming amount of chalkiness flavor. I don’t really taste the protein to be honest and I love that. The smell is definitely not it but for all the positives I can look past this one negative. This is affordable and a total hit for me!

Bought this for my husband to drink when his glucose level begins to dip. It smells moldy, but he said it doesn't taste bad. Still doesn't compare to chocolate Fairlife protein shakes purchased at Sam's. Doubtful we'll settle for this brand again, even if others are out of stock.

Loved them until I noticed a concerning ammount of blood in my stool, went to the doctor thinking it was something else only for him to ask what I've been eating, did an allergy test and told me to stop using it as the protein is whey... poof no more bloody stool! So sad because these are affordable and really good up until then!

Sam’s was out of Boost chocolate protein shake so I bought this as a substitute. They had plenty in stock and now I know why; this stuff is horrible. Doesn’t taste anything like chocolate but more like some flavored chalk! I tried cooling it down in the fridge and I believe it got worse. I like Sam’s club but this was a mistake and a waste of money. Hoping Boost or Fairlife is back in stock soon!

Pretty good for price and protein amount. Person who left one star review is being unreasonable. Many homeless would have been happy to drink what the debutante didn't want. Or return them. But they are comparable to many protein drinks on the market. Less sodium is my major complaint!

These shakes have a lot of protein and very little sugar, but still don't taste chalky or watery. It has a nice thick chocolate milk flavor and lots of vitamins and minerals for a very reasonable price. I use these instead of lunch when I'm on the go or stuck on a conference call at work. Highly recommend to anyone looking to replace a meal in a day or supplement their daily protein intake.

I decided to try this since the brand I buy is also 30 grams of protein and 1 gram of sugar. Tasted a little thicker but I liked it and will buy again. Equals to be $1.66 a bottle. The reviews that said chalky, maybe they didn't shake it up or serve it cold. .

Bought this because I thought it would be the same as Premier but less expensive. Could not use these shakes. Taste like chalk with strong unpleasant smell and aftertaste. Then there was the several hours of indigestion requiring multiple tums. Now, to return. Do not recommend!