The cookie dough tastes great, but the brownie batter is AWFUL and now I'm stuck with SO many of those I can't eat. I tried to trick my husband into liking them and he hated them too lol. Plus the consistency or texture is really difficult to get used to. It's like a marshmallow type center in every flavor... I bought 2 boxes from this brand of different flavors and they all have this weird marshmallow type consistency in the center that was really strange at first because you're not expecting it. I guess that's why they call it "puffs." but for me, I was expecting a protein bar... perhaps with texture and maybe ingredients that you taste separately? or idk how to put it but you know what a normal bar is like and this is basically like a chocolate covered marshmallow but the flavors are all different... obviously whatever you pick... but no matter what, the center is the same. very gooey.... not saying I hate that? crap these are really hard to explain. it's weird. But the cookie dough and the s'mores are the only ones I liked. And even then, it took some getting used to. The brownie one REALLY sucks!!

As a common gym goer, I HIGHLYYYYYY recommend this protein bar. Not only is it yummy and not have that weird protein after-flavor but it contains collagen. It’s so good, I’ve only had these two plus the coconut and I have no complaints. If you’re a little picky with texture, it’s similar to a marshmallow, soft and chewy (with the cookie dough having three pieces of cookie dough on top). I would 100% get more and stock up if I could.

Absolutely disgusting. This is not "puffy" at all, but instead is a dense gummy mass with the texture of a gum art eraser, certainly not a "fluffy marshmallow." The nutritional stats are great and the flavor is not awful but the texture is horrendous. I honestly don't know where all these great review ratings are coming from but this is by far the worst protein bar I have ever purchased and I have tried many MANY protein bars. The first bite stuck in my teeth and it took forever to melt and it felt like it was going to remain a giant ball of solid gum in my mouth for the longest time. Gross gross GROSS---DO NOT RECOMMEND!!!

These taste like tires. The texture, the smell, the taste. Rubber tires. I am so confused by the positive reviews and refuse to believe people have voluntarily eaten these without some kind of compensation. I'm no stranger to protein bars either. These are one of the worse things I've ever put in my mouth.

I have tried to like these… but it’s like a sponge covered with chocolate with a small ball of cookie dough on top. The taste is fine but the texture is terrible. Just can’t get on board with it. If you’re looking for a good alternative the fit crunch bars are the best I’ve found.

I just purchased these over this past weekend. I’m not sure if i got a bad batch or what’s going on, the brownie batter bar taste like pure chemicals, but the cookie dough was fine. I usually buy the brownie batter from my local walmart and they great! Don’t think i’ll buy these from sam’s club again.

Bought these for my 13 and 16 yr old sons. My 16 yr old loves cookie dough but couldn't stomach the texture. 13 yr old who loved marshmallows, also couldn't finish his first bite. The picture on the box looks like this is a Twix line bar. This is not a bar, but more of a chocolate covered gummy. But the center is more like so when between marshmallow and jelly. Now I'm not sure what to do with the remaining 13 bars.

These were definitely better than I thought they would be. I was actually pleasantly surprised when I tried these. I really dislike white chocolate and I thought that it was gonna taste like white chocolate and I wasn’t sure about the texture but these are delicious. Sooooo yummy and satisfying!

the texture of this is strange. honestly I was expecting the texture of a twix bar. the after taste of this is nasty nor does it taste like cookie dough. a thin layer of the marshmallow stuff would have been way better. crispy bottom (REAL)cookie dough flavor a chewy layer that isn't marshmallow texture would be way better. and a layer of cook crumbles on top of the chocolate.

Love. Love the cookie dough flavor. Hands down the best flavor!