I've been eating the Quaker Old Fashioned oats for years, but they are no longer carried at my club. You would think an oat is an oat, but these just aren't as good. They cook up gloopy no matter what adjustments I have tried. They work fine for baking, but aren't the best for breakfast.

We have been eating Quaker Old Fashioned Oats for decades and are very disappointed in the Makers Mark Old Fashioned Oats that was substituted. It is gummy and the taste is hard to adjust. We plan to trash both bags or return. It is a subpar oat that cooks more like instant oats. It requires more salt and molasses and the taste never improves! We will never purchase this product again! It is a disappointing substitute for the quality we are used to.

It's the best value. Please bring it back!!!!

As good as the name brand but with a lower price.

Terrible texture and flavor compared to Quaker. I do not recommend.

I agree with all of the one-star comments. Mush compared to Quaker. Extremely disappointing.

Top quality and realistic price

I make overnight oats with this and it turns out pretty good to me. I have used them for cookies and they were good. The price is also friendly.

The Members Mark is pasty compared to the Quaker Old Fashioned oatmeal. I'm switching back to Quaker next shopping trip.

Flavor and texture are comparable to namebrand. Price is great but can't have them anymore because they are not gluten free. Which is a shame.