It tastes like pumpkin with too much whipped cream on it. It has the slightest pumpkin spice flavor, but I like it. Not too sweet, but just right. Many other flavors of Premier are too sweet for me. I wish it was available more often. It would be my regular choice. My husband likes and buys chocolate.

If you are looking for something that tastes like pumpkin spice, this is not it. It made me sick every time with how artificial it tasted. I read the reviews, and a lot of people liked it, but if you are looking for something to replace your go-to fall drink, look elsewhere.

I mix this with 8oz cold brew, stevia, a splash of 1/2 & 1/2 and collagen powder. It is literally better than any “pumpkin” flavored drink from a mainstream coffee place. I have not tried it in hot coffee, only cold brew. It’s basically vanilla protein with some pumpkin spice flavor.

Big let down. Barely a hint of pumpkin in this shake.Tastes like a vanilla shake. Thankfully I only bought the 4 packs. I usually don’t like their vanilla and this flavor is almost exactly like it. Barely any pumpkin. I won’t waste the $8 I spent so I blend it with ice and some cinnamon to make it “fall” like. Won’t buy again though

This was my first time trying out this flavor and I'm in love. I'm bummed that it's a limited edition flavor because I'm a fall-loving pumpkin spice girly so when I saw this at my local Sam's I had to snag it up and try it. I gave one to my mom who used it in her coffee and she loved it as well. If you love pumpkin then you need to try this flavor, you will not regret it.

This is not the same shake as last year. I LOVED this so much last year I bought more than 10 cases. They changed the formula of the shake itself to make it "taste better" and they ruined it. Now, it's thin - like skim milk thin - and the taste is okay but watered down. I was so excited for this to come out this year and am now disappointed.

A lot of the flavors are hit or miss for me, but this one....wow! This is spot on, tastes just like pumpkin pie, absolutely delicious! I'm even trying to think of recipes I could use this for (hello creme brulee!) It's only available for a limited time, so I may have to buy some extras to stock up!

I really wanted to like this one but it is by far my least favorite. It does not taste like pumpkin. I taste something similar to caramel but not even as good as the caramel flavored shake. If you don't drink it immediately, it starts to taste funky. Don't even think about putting it back in the fridge. I'm so sad I prefer such a big case. I'd definitely return or exchange it if I could. A definite miss, to say the least.

I'm a big pumpkin spice fan and several people in my fitness group talked about how delicious these were, so I decided to buy a case. Unfortunately I didn't like them. They taste VERY sweet but not in a pleasant way. I have been putting a small amount in my coffee each day and they work great as a coffee creamer. I would recommend trying one first before committing to buying a large pack. A Lot of people I know love them but they are not for everyone.

I really enjoy the flavor of pumpkin and the spices used to flavor it--but this one misses the mark for me. Premier changed their formula many years ago and it just hasn't been the same. This flavor has to be really cold to drink for me. It's not terrible, but I wouldn't buy it again. We decided to try it since it was in sale.