I like pumpkin spice but this is the worst taste ever and left an awful nasty taste to remember it by. I managed to chock down half a bottle and just couldn't do any more. Save your money on this one!

I use these shakes as coffee creamer and while I do like this one, I will say the “pumpkin spice” is pretty subtle. Easy enough to punch it up with some spice from the jar with the red top, though, so that’s what I do…

Barf, vomit, puke let's see how many ways I can describe how this tastes? I kept putting off buying this since I used to be a faithful Premier customer but since the ridiculous price hikes that absolutely cannot be blamed solely on inflation. I broke down and bought these and the Cafe Latte (coffee flavored). I don't know what kind of pumpkin pie everyone is eating that says this tastes exactly like pumpkin pie because it definitely does not. It would need a lot more pumpkin pie spices to cover up the protein taste and to even come close to a pumpkin pie. I am keeping them in hopes that my husband will love them which he probably will. The best flavors are 1) caramel 2) banana 3) coffee 4) vanilla 5) chocolate 6) strawberry 7)peach 8)cookies n cream.--> In my professional opinion, of course lol. Did I say I used to be a faithful Premier customer?

Be careful and make sure they're good before you drink. I bought a case and they were all spoiled. Protein should never be fizzy. Why was it FIZZY? Needless to say, I came, I drank, I vomited, and I will never be buying these again. Also, customer service for the actually company is garbage, so you will not be getting your money back.

I was SO HOPEFUL that these shakes would be delicious because pumpkin is my absolute favorite flavor of anything!! I read the reviews before purchasing two boxes of 15 shakes, and I really did not want to believe the negative reviews!! I am very sorry to say that these shakes are disgusting IMHO!!! Some reviewers commented that these taste more like vanilla and people have added spices to help with the flavor. My experience, sadly, is that they taste like what I can only describe as “chemical paprika,” and I do not like the taste of paprika!! The taste is so strong and so much worse when they are cold from the fridge. They get a little more tolerable as they adjust to room temperature, but I do NOT like the taste of them at all!! I am so sad!! I’ve tried 3 of them on 3 different days, and two are still almost full. I HAD TO get another flavor from the fridge today because I can’t imagine trying to drink another one of these. I tried the Cake Batter flavor just this month and I do enjoy the taste, so that’s the one I’m drinking today. Caramel is my favorite, but I also really like the Bananas and Cream flavor as well!! Of all of the other flavors I have tried (Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberries and Cream, Cinnamon Roll, Caramel, Bananas and Cream, Cake Batter), I have liked the taste of them even if they don’t exactly hit the mark of what they’re supposed to taste like, but these “pumpkin spice” shakes are just nasty to me. If they tasted like Vanilla, I would have enjoyed them. I am so sad because I love pumpkin flavor so much and try to find it wherever possible. I wonder if I might have gotten a bad batch?? It would be great if this were true.

I really enjoyed these protein shakes. They go great mixed with coffee.

Taste horrible and absolutely no pumpkin flavor whatsoever.

It’s lite not thick like the caramel. Nice after taste of the pumpkin flavor.

I usually love Pumpkin Spice but these are awful!!

Very disappointing. Completely lacking in flavor. Tastes nothing like pumpkin.