[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have 4 cats within my family that I gave this wet food to. 2 out of 4 loved it...They wouldn’t walk away, they devoured it! The other 2 wouldn’t even taste it. One is a picky eater but the other cat eats just about anything and still wouldn’t touch it. It smelt fine and they seemed attracted to it but it was a split reaction. Neither of the 2 that ate it had an adverse reaction.

I bought this for the first time 3 weeks ago bought a case of it. Man was that a bad move on my part. I have 24 cans left and they won't touch it. It's extremely dry. Zero gravy, and it's so thick I literally have to chop it with a fork to brak it into bite size pieces. My cats begrudgingly ate a few bites and most of it goes bad. My cats are not picky, this can not be what the company thinks is quality food. Especially for the price! I've read they're was a recipe Charme a few years ago. I honestly thought I'd gotten a bad batch. I will not be buying this brand of wet food again. I was trying to find better healthier food for my fur babies. This was a huge swing and a miss!! You should be ashamed of yourself Blue Buffalo for having this poor quality and the price tag attached to it. Booooo two thumbs down!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] my cats are very picky and the only wet cat food they eat is Sheeba turkey pate. unfortunately, they didn't like this. it smells just like chicken and I would think if your cats like real chicken they would love this. I'm sad my cats didn't bc it has better ingredients then the one that like.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My picky eater ate every bite of her blue tasteful chicken pate’ and even licked the bowl. She was so excited while I was trying to get it into her dish she was eating it off the spoon as I dipped it. I will be purchasing this product for her from now on

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My cats have been a little finicky lately so my husband fed them Blue Tastefuls Ocean Fish & Tuna. I noticed right away the food looks to have a nice gravy consistency. and the cats thought so too. LOL! They liked every single drop out of that bowl, and now when I feed them they line up and wait. They had never been excited about being fed before. New loyal customers here!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Yes he did he really liked it. I go thru a lot of different foods and he don’t like some and won’t eat them but he ate this with no problems. So my picky eating cat live it… it must be good! I recommend this to picky eaters!

We started buying BLUE tasteful for our adult cat a few weeks ago. We noticed inventory that was mixed with blue colored lids and others were just silver. We no longer can find the colored ones. The cat food is not the same! Please bring back the “blue lid” formula! Our cat won’t eat the new food.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received the Blue Buffalo Ocean Fish and Tuna cat food as a free sample. I was already familiar with the quality of Blue Buffalo so did not hesitate to give it to my senior (and a bit overweight) cat to try. He gobbled it right up and then flung the bowl off the shelf in a frenzy. I am going to take that as a sign he liked it. I will definitely put this in the rotation.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Doesn't smell bad and our cats really were interested and gobbled it down. Great brand. The cats are happy and so am I. Bothell my 6 year old and 1 year old cat liked it. Highly recommend to people.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have 2 cats who recently tried Blue Tastefuls Chicken Pate. One cat ate it and the other one wouldn’t touch it. I noticed a lot of other people in the reviews said their cats didn't like it either. I won’t be repurchasing.