We’re so sorry to hear that the Tastefuls Variety Pack, Pate Wet Cat Food didn’t appeal to your kitty. Every cat has their own preferences, and sometimes it just takes a bit of trial and error to find the right match. Alternatively, you can explore other options using our product tools here: https://bluebuffalo.com/product-finder/cat/or https://bluebuffalo.com/dog-and-cat-food-product-recommender/cat-food-recommender/. Let us know how it goes, we appreciate you giving it a try!