Terrible soup if you want to call it that. I had it over six months ago and it was good. Now it is very liquid like water. The soup has no cheddar flavor at all. It is a very strange flavor like vegetables boiled in water. I am extremely disappointed. They did away with Panera to replace it with garbage. Do not recommend that you buy this water, ...er...I mean soup .

Quite literally the worst soup I have ever had. It’s incredible thin and I can’t even begin to explain how terrible the flavors are in the soup. Maybe something was just wrong with mine in particular but I wouldn’t give this to my worst enemy. Just terrible.

Remember when President George H.W. Bush admitted that he didn’t like broccoli? Well, I bet he hadn’t been served a good broccoli cheddar soup before! Sometimes the right recipe makes all the difference for someone to appreciate certain vegetables. :) Pouring this over chicken can be enjoyable, too.

I purchased Members Mark Broccoli and cheddar soup one week ago. Decided to make it for dinner last night. There was a lot of mold towards the top of the container, then a whole lot of mold in the middle of container. My spouse is currently on chemotherapy and, if he would have eaten this, it would have made him extremely sick. I cannot believe Sams Club would sell this product. It is wrong to not have quality control in place for all food products.

I loved the broccoli cheese soup up until Feb 2022. Must have switched copackers because now the soup is just full of fibrous broccoli stalks that have to be spit out. I loved that it was vegetarian, but now is just full of gross fibrous stems. so sad

The Panera Broccoli Cheddar Soup was a favorite of mines, so I bought this one with high expectations because Member Mark foods are you usually great quality. This is soup is editable, but it’s not good enough to make me want to purchase it again. There is a lingering after taste as well. Hopefully it grows on me as I eat the rest of the two containers.

I expected the soup to look like the picture (little pieces of broccoli and carrots), but it has more of a creamy texture. I added frozen broccoli, so that was an easy fix. I also added more cheese on top. The taste was good, so even without the extras, I would purchase it again.

It's not like Panera, it's not like Culver's. It's not great, I mean it tastes like cream of no flavor, but you can tell there's salt or whatever. Seriously, I'm not a big negative review guy, but I've been wanting soup lately so I tried this. I hope it's healthy because it's not great. Standard Campbell's chicken noodle at least had flavor. I have no idea what the good reviews are eating, but it isn't this. Again, it's not like it went bad, just no flavor. Like when you get poor quality chocolate and it feels like good chocolate, but the flavor of good chocolate just isn't there.

I used to love this soup! Haven't had it for ~ 6 mos then this week purchased again.....3 pkgs of 2. Have eaten 2 containers and there is an ingredient that is unedible. Like little sticks, stiff stems. I thought maybe they added asparagus, but that veggie isn't listed as an ingredient. Not sure what it is. Just disgusting. So, returning the other 2 pkgs.

I bought this soup at Sam's because I thought it was the real rich and thick and creamy brand that I had purchased before. I was mistaken, I had purchased it at a different Warehouse. I prefer the Kirkland brand over the Member's Mark. Once you've had the Kirkland brand you will never purchase this watered-down soup. It doesn't even have the same flavor. It's a never again for me.