Nearly identical to Panera's soup. The Members Mark is not quite as salty - which is a good thing - and it has a tiny little kick to it from black pepper. It's very good, and I will buy it again.

This soup was great when we first started buying it a couple years ago but the last couple times we purchased it was just very watery. Don't know what they changed but it should definitely have a thicker consistency.

What happened? The soup is thin now, and tastes watered down. Before it was a thicker consistency %26 better flavor. Guess I'm gonna have to buy the Panera one now, and I had liked yours more until the change. So disappointed!!

Bland and tasteless. Woody chunks of broccoli and a strong taste of processed fake cheddar cheese. Will not buy again. Disappointing since almost always have a positive experience with Members Mark products.

Not like any other broccoli cheddar soup we've ever had. Taste and texture was not there, a hint of cheese maybe. Going to be spending the extra couple dollars on name brands that taste better.

WAYYYYY too much PEPPER. That is ALL I taste. can't taste the broccoli, carrots or the cheddar!! The veggies are undercooked, practically raw. would not recommend and wil not purchase again. YUCK

This soup is delicious. I like a little spice so I add some cayenne pepper to it and black pepper. I always serve it with a crusty piece of bread either sourdough or baguette.

I'm not sure if I got a bad container or what, but I am baffled by all of the great reviews. The only broccoli was the stems, no crowns, and it had a weird taste. It did not taste like cheddar or broccoli, just a funky artificial taste.

Bought this on a whim. I've had it 2x, and there's at least another bowl left. But so far, there has not been a single floret of broccoli - only stems, or more like stalks! Also gets very thin when heated. Not a fan. Won't buy again.

I was looking for the Panera brand but my local Sam’s Club doesn’t carry it. I was very hesitant to buy this one because I didn’t want to he disappointed if the taste wasn’t great. I am so glad I bought this one! The taste is very good! It’s not exactly like Panera’s Broccoli Cheddar Soup but it’s still veryyy good. You will not be disappointed!