I've always bought Panera's broccoli soup, but it's gotten way too expensive, and store bought is never as good as buying direct. I tried Member's Mark and I'm sold. It is creamy, thick and rich, with a touch of heat. I'm not a fan of spicy foods, so this is perfect. I joined Sam's in order to get a less expensive price, rather than Instacart. But, this soup is absolutely delicious. Don't pay attention to online "opinions" about white beans being a secret ingredient. I Googled it and "AI" results say yes, beans are in it, and another AI generated result says "no". You just can't trust AI.

My spouse and I are very happy with this! Panera's version has gone downhill, watery and bland and overpriced. This is so superior! My favorite way to use it is eating it as is with side salad OR when I make boxed mac n cheese, I add this to the pot at the end and sometimes throw in a can of corn, so tasty!

I look for this soup every time I go into Sam's, but they ran out about a month ago and haven't replaced it. There's an herb that is too strong. I think it is either oregano or basil, but it is the closest to the original that I've tried so far. I intend to keep buying it as long as they keep making it available and don't increase the price too much.

Quite literally the worst soup I have ever had. It’s incredible thin and I can’t even begin to explain how terrible the flavors are in the soup. Maybe something was just wrong with mine in particular but I wouldn’t give this to my worst enemy. Just terrible.

I have recently had half of my tongue removed and radiation zapped my taste buds to where I can't taste nearly anything and it's hard to swallow. So I got this soup. I'm used to soft broccoli. This is like they just slapped crowns in cheese and let it go without cooking. It's pretty stiff. I run my soup through a processor due to most having chunks I don't want to choke on. So this is spicy? I've never had that with broccoli and cheddar. It's just supposed to be that. Not sure what's up with that? I had someone else taste it. It is. I'll just stick to the Walmart version (why is that different when it's the same company?) that's thin and or Panera which makes it correctly.

The Panera Broccoli Cheddar Soup was a favorite of mines, so I bought this one with high expectations because Member Mark foods are you usually great quality. This is soup is editable, but it’s not good enough to make me want to purchase it again. There is a lingering after taste as well. Hopefully it grows on me as I eat the rest of the two containers.

I expected the soup to look like the picture (little pieces of broccoli and carrots), but it has more of a creamy texture. I added frozen broccoli, so that was an easy fix. I also added more cheese on top. The taste was good, so even without the extras, I would purchase it again.

This product is stocked in two open cooler locations in my store and neither had a price posted above it. Both signage holders were there but empty. The price at the register was acceptable so we purchased it. It also had an instant coupon. You'll have more sales if you post you're pricing and instant coupon to in-store browsing customers.

I purchased this product the other day and served it tonight with dinner. The package says it doesn't expire until over a month away. It was horrible! It tasted like the smell of baby formula vomit with a grainy texture. I'm not sure how this has a single good review. I took 1 bite and the rest is going in the trash.

Was highly disappointed. Very bland, it just didn't have any Flavor. I even tried to add extra pepper and cheese, it just didn't help. And I was very much in the mood for soup during this cold Winter storm here in Michigan. And I have tried other member mark soup and not been disappointed like this one was.