These were the exact sugar cookies you crave without even realizing youre craving them. Literally the perfect sugar cookie. The icing isnt overly sweet and the cookie is buttery!

Your holiday cut out cookies with the decorative frosting, rock! My wife and I really like them so they need to be a regular item not just for holidays.

TMI, the food dye in the green cookies makes your pee green. The green cookie versus all the rest also had a chemical taste, it's definitely the dye. We had gotten the other cutout cookies before, the one with the yellow leaf and they're great. That green one though, for taste and after effects are gross. Please discontinue the green color.

They're pretty good! I suspect that whatever they use to color the green ones is causing a slight bitter aftertaste though, and my pee was straight neon green after eating it 💚💚💚 I mean it looked like it would glow in the dark if I turned out the lights. I mean Charli XCX probably ate these cookies before having an epiphany about what the album cover for brat should be. Would still eat them again though!!! 🤠

Pretty, Granddaughter had to have them instead of the variety pack of chocolate chunk, oatmeal raisin and White Chunk Macadamia. We each took a nibble and immediately rejected them, Beaux and Bella, our Boston Terriers, would not even accept a morsel.

I'm giving 3 stars for the pumpkin and mummy cookies but would like to let SC know that green cookie requires too much green coloring making the cookie taste almost metallic. I made my fiance try a bite to make sure it wasn't just me and he said the same thing and actually opted for a shot of whiskey to get the taste out of his mouth. It really was so bad we threw all the green ones away. Otherwise the mummy and pumpkin are delicious!

I love these cookies, i have tried the star cookies, the fall cookies, and they are amazing, that said, the green Halloween cookies, the green icing was bitter, the pumpkin and ghost were very good, but the green ones tasted ok, but the icing was bitter, love these cookies they just need to stop using cheep food dyes.

Love the Sam’s sugar cookies! I’ve introduced them to 4 different family members and they are our favorites!

Delicious Halloween-themed cookies at a great price! They were gobbled up in a flash at a recent party

Beautiful and tasty cookies, I love these seasonal shortbread cookies and the best part is they're dye free!