The orange and white cookies were excellent. However, the green cookies were horrible. Whatever dye was used for the green coloring was not good at all. I’ve had these cookies in other shapes and colors before, and every other color was very good. My other family members feel the same.

I am a fan of the Sam’s seasonalholiday iced cookies. However. the the green icing on this Halloween group has a very odd bitterness taste.

To much artifical food die. Had to take an allergy pill for hive reaction. Green ones leave a horrible taste in your mouth. Cookies were soft and orange and white ones tasted delicious but after effects were horrible.

Spookily good: These are amazing sugar cookies dipped in chocolate. Had them at a meeting when someone brought them. I had to join Sam's Club just so I could buy them myself.

The white iced cookies taste good. The cookies with the colored icing is gross. You can taste the food coloring in it and just ruins the whole cookie.

Very good cookies. Everyone loved them and got a kick out of the funny faces on the monster. They are filling and it only takes 1 to fill you up. The vanilla flavor is very flavorful.

I bought these cookies to serve at book club. They were beautifully decorated and tasted amazing. They are bakery quality at a fraction of the price. I will buy these for each holiday.

I love these cookies. I buy them for every season or holiday that they’re out. Are they healthy? By no means. But are they delicious? Absolutely. Solid 10/10

I bought these cookies for Halloween, and they were terrible. They had a strong, unpleasant taste — almost like too much food coloring or something artificial. My family couldn’t eat them at all. Definitely would not recommend.

These cookies are always a hit with company and friends. They are very tasty, appealing to the eye, and a great value. Will always be our go-to when bringing treats.