Customer reviews for Member's Mark Halloween Cutout Cookies, 15 ct. forMember's Mark Halloween Cutout Cookies, 15 ct.
Most helpful positive review
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Freaking love these cookies
Natalie
Most helpful negative review
1 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Horrible — Not Edible
Albert
442 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/1/2025The orange and white cookies were excellent. However, the green cookies were horrible. Whatever dye was used for the green coloring was not good at all. I've had these cookies in other shapes and colors before, and every other color was very good. My other family members feel the same.
Very good, except green ones.
Theresa - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/23/2025I love these cookies. I buy them for every season or holiday that they’re out. Are they healthy? By no means. But are they delicious? Absolutely. Solid 10/10
Freaking love these cookies
Natalie - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/7/2025The white iced cookies taste good. The cookies with the colored icing is gross. You can taste the food coloring in it and just ruins the whole cookie.
No thanks
TJ - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/14/2025Spookily good: These are amazing sugar cookies dipped in chocolate. Had them at a meeting when someone brought them. I had to join Sam's Club just so I could buy them myself.
Spookily Good
AnnaPag - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/5/2025I bought these cookies for Halloween, and they were terrible. They had a strong, unpleasant taste — almost like too much food coloring or something artificial. My family couldn't eat them at all. Definitely would not recommend.
Horrible — Not Edible
Albert - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/31/2025To much artifical food die. Had to take an allergy pill for hive reaction. Green ones leave a horrible taste in your mouth. Cookies were soft and orange and white ones tasted delicious but after effects were horrible.
Don't purchase these
Anonymous - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/5/2025These cookies are always a hit with company and friends. They are very tasty, appealing to the eye, and a great value. Will always be our go-to when bringing treats.
Great taste and great value
Tom - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/12/2025I bought these cookies to serve at book club. They were beautifully decorated and tasted amazing. They are bakery quality at a fraction of the price. I will buy these for each holiday.
Amazing Cookies
Shar W - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/6/2025Very good cookies. Everyone loved them and got a kick out of the funny faces on the monster. They are filling and it only takes 1 to fill you up. The vanilla flavor is very flavorful.
Halloween Cookies
PATTY - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/23/2025Great designs but for decoration only. Not a good tasting cookie at all. Won’t buy again! Took 2 trays to a party and embarrassed they tasted awful.
Looks good but….
Bengi - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/20/2025Tried two cookies. Weird taste. Caused urine to turn bright yellow for two of us that ate a cookie. Trashed the rest.
Sugar Cookies
JW - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/29/2025The pumpkin and mummy sugar cookies were good but the green ones not good at all. Left a very bad aftertaste.
Good, not great
MIKE - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/10/2025My husband bought them for work, and everyone oohh and aaahhh about how amazing they were. Everyone loved them!!!
EVERYONE LOVED THEM
Happy customer - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/23/2025I am a fan of the Sam's seasonalholiday iced cookies. However. the the green icing on this Halloween group has a very odd bitterness taste.
Green cookies are off tasting.
Craig - 4 out of 5 stars review11/21/2025I love these cookies, i have tried the star cookies, the fall cookies, and they are amazing, that said, the green Halloween cookies, the green icing was bitter, the pumpkin and ghost were very good, but the green ones tasted ok, but the icing was bitter, love these cookies they just need to stop using cheep food dyes.Mary
- 3 out of 5 stars review11/21/2025I'm giving 3 stars for the pumpkin and mummy cookies but would like to let SC know that green cookie requires too much green coloring making the cookie taste almost metallic. I made my fiance try a bite to make sure it wasn't just me and he said the same thing and actually opted for a shot of whiskey to get the taste out of his mouth. It really was so bad we threw all the green ones away. Otherwise the mummy and pumpkin are delicious!
Green cookies taste bad
KRISTINA - 4 out of 5 stars review11/21/2025They're pretty good! I suspect that whatever they use to color the green ones is causing a slight bitter aftertaste though, and my pee was straight neon green after eating it 💚💚💚 I mean it looked like it would glow in the dark if I turned out the lights. I mean Charli XCX probably ate these cookies before having an epiphany about what the album cover for brat should be. Would still eat them again though!!! ðŸ¤
Good Cookies!
WINSTON - 4 out of 5 stars review11/21/2025TMI, the food dye in the green cookies makes your pee green. The green cookie versus all the rest also had a chemical taste, it's definitely the dye. We had gotten the other cutout cookies before, the one with the yellow leaf and they're great. That green one though, for taste and after effects are gross. Please discontinue the green color.
Unexpected surprise
Melanie - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/2/2025Not very flavorful. Tasted waxy and artificial. Cute but yucky tasting.
Cute but terrible tasting
BowWow12 - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/26/2025Rivals any bakery cookie out there!
DEEElicious!
3badboysmom