Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Loaded Potato Salad, 3 lbs. for
Member's Mark Loaded Potato Salad, 3 lbs.

Member photos

  • +1 image
Sort by |
Showing 561-570 of 624 reviews
May 16, 2025
FS171chick
4 out of 5 stars review

My Family Liked It

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. My whole family liked it. We haven't demolished the entire container yet and that's why I took a star away. If it were 5 star material, it would be gone in 3 days. The salad is very tasty and filling. I agree with some that it is a bit "saucy," and the potatoes could be cut just a tad smaller. That's not a deal breaker for me though. I would buy this again.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 14, 2025
Kari
3 out of 5 stars review

Just OK in my opinion

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. I tried the Loaded Potato Salad and it was just ok in my opinion. It is definitely not like traditional potato salad if that's what you are looking for. It was a little soupy for my liking and it just wasn't very flavorful. I would say that if you like this kind of thing it is a good value. I would not buy this again.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 14, 2025
Jack
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible

You taste everthing except potatoes. Way to much sour cream and chives. Went in the trash after my wife and I tried it. I actually felt sick the folliwing day, im sure its the club locations fault, probably l left out of the frig for to long before being stocked.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
Jul 3, 2025
Puchuita
1 out of 5 stars review

No, no, no...

We received this as psrt of a hostess gift. This is only good for folks that generally eat what is considered over processed and over seasoned food. The mayo/sour cream blend taste like the worst version of them and the cheddar cheese flavor is dominant and overly processed tasting. I cannot even recall the bacon flavor due to how bad the bad cheddar dominates. Sorry! Went into serving this expecting this to not come close to homemade. The five of us at home have different food criteria and all of us said toss it! Unless we received a bad one...

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 28, 2025
HockeyMom27
5 out of 5 stars review

Delicious and our friends thought it was homemade!

*received reimbursement for this honest review I really liked this potato salad. My family and guests enjoyed it with ribs and other sides for a cookout. I didn't leave it out in the container - instead I put it in a serving bowl and had multiple inquiries for the recipe! It's cheesy and delicious without being overwhelming. My husband is not a fan of anything with mayo/sour cream and he loved this! Will definitely buy again!!

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 17, 2025
ash78
5 out of 5 stars review

Loaded potato in a container

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review, the potato salad tasted really good and have a good texture, it almost tasted like a loaded potato that you get at a restaurant but cold. it goes well with BBQ or any meal at home. the package is nice and easy to open and a very nice size that easily can feed 8-12 people, great for occasions like Memorial Day and 4th of July BBQs. will buy again.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 12, 2025
cfm922
4 out of 5 stars review

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. This potato salad is really good. The chives don't give it too much of an "onion" flavor. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because I felt like it was too creamy, with too much sauce.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 13, 2025
KoolKatK
4 out of 5 stars review

Great taste and consistency but could use...

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review, I admit, I was slightly motivated to try this Potato Salad but I am glad that I did. This is a good sized amount of potato salad that fed 2 adults and 2 teen boys in one sitting. We did eat the entire container and the taste is great! I would have never considered adding sour cream in a potato salad but that's what made this nearly taste like a loaded potato. The potatoes are sliced thin, instead of chunky and that I really liked. (I may borrow this concept for future potato salads) and I feel made the flavors taste better. I rated 4/5 because while the taste is good, I feel it could be better with more chives/onion flavor, more bacon/ham flavor and texture. There was no ham in this one but I feel it is the missing link. Overall, I will purchase this again as it was a hit with the teen boys.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 13, 2025
Kim
1 out of 5 stars review

Awful!

I had to rush on here to tell my story. I served 7 people off of this and nobody would eat it. Everyone spit it out and my daughter threw up. She does have a sensitive stomach though but said it tasted like elmers school glue. Proceed with caution, it might be for you but it wasn't good for my family.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659
May 28, 2025
Galaxi
3 out of 5 stars review

Like a loaded baked potato with extra sour cream

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. Potato salad. No two taste alike. Everyone likes them different - firmer potato chunks in sauce, creamy kinda mashed types, sweet, sour, mustard, egg, mayo, etc. I'm typically a dill eggy mustard creamy potato salad kind of person. This is one EXTRA creamy. It has a sour cream and mayo base. The texture is good as far as chunk of potatoes in the cream base. It also has some shredded cheddar cheese, chives and bacon bits in it. I definitely added more bacon and a touch more salt to it to enhance it a bit better. It's not overly sweet or sour, it's got balance in that regard. I personally think it eats better warmed up as it tastes more like a loaded baked potato au gratin. I think they should cut out some of the binders like the carrageenan, corn starch and the sodium phosphate (because who really needs that anyway). All in all, it's not bad or amazing. If you don't like sour cream or it's texture - skip. If you love a good creamy baked potato, you probably would like it. But it's definitely thiiiick when cold.

Helpful?1DRP5151AG0O13596852659