Buying more for the 4th holiday because we tasted it and now it's gone in 2 days. Just a dash of salt and pepper and it's perfect.

Rotten dark potatoes.

tad bit salty

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review, I admit, I was slightly motivated to try this Potato Salad but I am glad that I did. This is a good sized amount of potato salad that fed 2 adults and 2 teen boys in one sitting. We did eat the entire container and the taste is great! I would have never considered adding sour cream in a potato salad but that's what made this nearly taste like a loaded potato. The potatoes are sliced thin, instead of chunky and that I really liked. (I may borrow this concept for future potato salads) and I feel made the flavors taste better. I rated 4/5 because while the taste is good, I feel it could be better with more chives/onion flavor, more bacon/ham flavor and texture. There was no ham in this one but I feel it is the missing link. Overall, I will purchase this again as it was a hit with the teen boys.

I had to rush on here to tell my story. I served 7 people off of this and nobody would eat it. Everyone spit it out and my daughter threw up. She does have a sensitive stomach though but said it tasted like elmers school glue. Proceed with caution, it might be for you but it wasn't good for my family.

You taste everthing except potatoes. Way to much sour cream and chives. Went in the trash after my wife and I tried it. I actually felt sick the folliwing day, im sure its the club locations fault, probably l left out of the frig for to long before being stocked.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. This potato salad is really good. The chives don't give it too much of an "onion" flavor. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because I felt like it was too creamy, with too much sauce.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. I wanted to LOVE this product. I am a huge baked potato fan and even more so when loaded. I immediately grabbed a bowl when I arrived home with it. I must say you can see the cheese and bacon. That was a nice surprise. I was not pleased. I added salt. This does not mean that everyone would. I am the type that will put salt on a side of salt before I taste something. The salt was not needed and did not enhance the taste of this. I then decided maybe I should try it after it had been in the refrigerator a bit and was more like what you would have when buying it for a reason other than a review. It was much better. I love that you can taste the cheese and bacon. This is where the good ends. It is creamy but I cannot tell what is causing the creaminess. It does not taste like sour cream or the normal mayo or mustard. It is just a bland creaminess. This is not a bad product but not something I will buy again.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. My whole family liked it. We haven't demolished the entire container yet and that's why I took a star away. If it were 5 star material, it would be gone in 3 days. The salad is very tasty and filling. I agree with some that it is a bit "saucy," and the potatoes could be cut just a tad smaller. That's not a deal breaker for me though. I would buy this again.

extremely decadent ... which i thought i'd never say about potato salad. it is very good & i particularly like the chunky eggs & chunky potatoes & potato skin peels ... tho it is almost too much. i recommend, but i think i'd prefer a regular ole potato salad.