Amazing

Good

This was horrible, it has way too much mayo or sour cream. Not the potato salad for me, it went in the trash and this girl loves everything and I hate wasting food.

Needed potato salad and this was the only one Sam's had. Our family all thought it tasted awful and inedible. It had an artificial taste to it, not good one bit. We usually love Members Mark products, but not this. Do not recommend!

I had placed a pick up order the weekend of easter only to find out I was given a 3 month expired potato salad. Luckily it wasnt everyones go to side and that I didn't get sick.

worst potato salad I've every had I couldn't even give it away to my friends because they. say the same I thought this would be a easy side for a decent get together I thought wrong. normally Sam's brands are good just this time it's not for me .

Salty, too mayo-y and not my cup of tea...I accidentally ordered the loaded potatoes somehow instead of my favorite, the plain old potato salad, which is, to me, very very good. I didn't realize it until I opened it and took a bite. Yikes, not what I expected to taste, and I tried having some more once I realized my error in case it was just the shock of not what I expected, but nope, this is a total miss for me, if it was less salty and had less mayo...maybe.

I really like this potato salad. I think it gives a good homemade flavor. Its the only brand i am not embarrassed to bring when i don't have time to do it from scratch and really, by the time you buy everything to make it this is WAY cheaper!! Last weekend i crumbled some bacon on top and some fresh cheddar cheese -put it in my own bowl and no one was any wiser!

I had high hopes for this potato salad. I've had another “loaded” type potato salad before and it was delish! This one is just lacking in that “loaded potato” flavoring. It just tastes blah. No one at the party cared for it and it ended up in the trash, unfortunately.

WARNING DON'T BUY THIS DISQUISTING POTATO SALAD!!!! I only could eat about two fork fulls and stopped because of the terrible taste!!! My Brother and other friends had the same experience. Now on the other hand if you try the other Sam's club potato salad that comes in a 5lb container you'll really enjoy that, and to be brutally honest I'm shocked they are still selling that NASTY LOADED POTATO SALAD!!!!!!