This pie is way too sweet...I had over half a pie left with 12 people, 6 of them teenagers with only popcorn as the other option! Just not good.

Flavor and taste very inconsistent. Different every time like they have several different recipes and roll the dice to see which one to use.

Never write reviews but this pie wasn’t it. Had an off putting artificial taste and the key lime flavor was just not there. Whipped topping was a texture nightmare. Just No.

Sam's has perfected their recipe. There is definitely a great balance between tart and sweet. Even the whip cream has a nice taste and consistency.

This is perhaps the most disappointing (of several poor items) baked products from Sam's club. It had nearly no lime flavor. It's incredibly bland. I threw more than half of it away....never again.

The filling is okay bu trot enough punch to the flavor. key lime is supposed to be subtle but this is way too subtle. The crust was good and not too hard but it needs more flavor. Also, the whipped topping is too sweet.

I looked forward to this pie every season! But, I was very disappointed that the pie was down sized and the price stayed the same. That in itself will keep me from purchasing.

Tried Sam's Key Lime pie for the first time and was very disappointed. Tastes like lots and lots of sugar and very little key lime. Key Lime pie is a family favorite, but no one liked it.

I love the ridiculousness of the reviewer that is complaining that this dessert has unhealthy ingredients. It's a pie not health food. You kinda know what you're getting into when you buy a dessert.

Hard to find good Key Lime pie away from Florida. I usually get it at Publix when we are in Florida. Sam's Club Key Lime Pie is every bit as good. Nice lime taste and the crust is better than Publix. I know it says for a limited time but I do hope they carry it all year!