Go back to the old recipe. It’s overly sweet and not tart. The crust tastes like ginger snap cookies, instead of graham crackers, and way too crumbly.

The filling is okay bu trot enough punch to the flavor. key lime is supposed to be subtle but this is way too subtle. The crust was good and not too hard but it needs more flavor. Also, the whipped topping is too sweet.

Purchased for neighborhood party. Many of us love key lime pie and this did NOT disappoint. It was a great balance of key lime filling, amazing crust all complemented by the whip topping. A nice combination of refreshing and indulgent! I will definitely buy again.

I cannot believe that this pie has 4.5 stars. Have all these other people never have a decent key lime pie? I was unable to identify any key lime flavor. It most resembled an artificial lemon flavored dessert from a low price buffet. It is gooey, heavy, overly sweet, and it had way too much crust, although the filling was so unappealing, it's kind of good that there was too much crust. The unidentifiably artificial and unpleasant. Also, if you are ordering this online, as I was, and are used to the pies from another membership store, this is just a regular sized pie, not the extra large (delicious) kind you might expect. Purchased as a birthday treat, and disappointing to the point of embarrassing. Literally sprinkled regular lime juice on top of it to try to get some citrus flavor added.

No flavor more cream than lime

Flavorful refreshing and so yummy

Great flavor, size and price!

Not overly tart. Not overly sweet.

this pie is always a winner when i bring it to Pot Luck dinners.

Delicious , mild lime taste , creamy , good crust!