This pie was so tart. You couldn't taste anything else. I bought it because some reviewers said it wasn't tart but sweet... not THIS pie! No one in the house ate more than a bite befire tossing their piece in the trash. The rest of the pie followed. Sorry but nuu-huh, no sir. That was $10 down the dang drain.

Grabbed this because I kept seeing people online say it's the best key lime pie. I'll skip it and just make my own from now on. The flavor was just meh. It was really lacking the punch a home made key lime pie has. I bought this for Easter and had several people say they recommend not wasting the money for this one again. Great price point for anyone who needs a quick and easy pie for an event though!

I needed a large pie for Father's Day, and your Key Lime pies normally are large. Unfortunately, on this day, they were small pies, but still had the price of your normally large ones. I had to purchase anyway, but had to also get an additional dessert. I noticed when I went back after the holiday, the large pies had magically returned.

Bought 2, for the first time ever, at the Davenport Sam's on April 1st, 2022. Fantastic!! Hope this is something that will be on the shelves for a long time. Excellent lime taste. Will be buying a few more for the freezer if they still have them available on my next visit.

I bought this twice, once over a month ago and then it was the best key lime we had ever had. So we got it again for this Christmas, and instead, it had almost no flavor of the key lime at all. Very disappointing and we will not get it again unless the quality returns.

I was hoping for more of a punch of lime and tartness. What I tasted was a mellow lime flavor without any tart. Added to that, the whipped cream wasn’t a real whipped cream but an overly sweet whipped meringue-cream that added more sweet to the already too sweet pie. I was quite disappointed.

Had high hopes as most items from the bakery are quite tasty. This however is an exception. I should have known better at the appearance was vary pale when compared to other key lime pies. Most have a green tint, even some visible lime peel shavings. None on this pie. And when we did try a piece, completely bland. No tart or lime flavor at all. It tasted like a whip cream pie. Sadly, like the other reviews, the rest went into the trash. Bummer.

this pie was really good. i gave it 4 stars only because the deliciousness & fluffiness only lasted a few days. it was a pretty big pie therefore me & my son couldn't finish it right away. eventhough i liked how it tasted at first, i don't think i will buy it again unless it is to be consumed right away as in a party or as a dessert at a meal for a number of people.

I've purchased this several times in the past. It was always delicious and not too sweet you could really taste the tart lime flavor but this time there seems to be a different taste. They have definitely messed with the recipe and not for the better. I won't buy again. Tell me why would you change it.

A great-tasting pie. The crust is phenomenal. I'm not a graham cracker crust fan, and this one doesn't taste like graham cracker to me. It's much better. The filling is very creamy, and it tastes great. It is a nice thickness, not too much or too little. It could use a little more key lime tartness, but I love tart/citrus desserts and some people don't. But in fairness, every key lime pie I have bought in the past has not had a huge key lime pop. The topping is real whipped cream. A little zest of lime and a thin slice on top would make it a total show-stopper. Sam's Club please keep this pie! Signed, Member's Mark Key Lime Pies #1 Fan