Had I not sampled last year, probably would have never tried. It is excellent and we have purchased several since then. Have tried another key lime pie from a competitor, just doesn’t compare.

This is the best key lime pie I have had. The balance of the whipped topping and pie is perfect. And, it tastes like they used real key limes. I wish they would add the whipped topping to the whole pie so I can have some with every bite.

This pie was delicious! I'm a snob about key lime pies because they tend to use weird flavorings or it's too bitter. Not this one! It was perfect and the whipped cream and soft crust was perfection, I was very impressed.

The pie itself is rather stiff, not creamy like I had hoped. The "whipped cream" is really, well, I have no idea what it is, but it is definitely NOT whipped cream. The crust is very good.

The Member's Mark Key Lime Pie taste GREAT! Reminds me of when Red Lobster was exclusive but not anymore. I high recommend Sam's Club Key Lime Pie for anytime. It's light tangy key lime flavor is FANTASTIC!

Absolutely outstanding. Perfect, smooth texture with high notes of lime blended with stuff cream. A textural delight. Best. Ever. Graham cracker crust with a hint of real butter! Yes, real butter! Highly recommend!

My husband loves this pie. He didn’t care for the cream frosting topping. Said it was too much. Best to use your offset spreader to spread it all over the pie as a topping.

I thought i didnt like key lime pie but this one has changed my mind. Its sweet with a HINT of tart and the size was huge. It lasted 2 of us a week to eat.

Key lime pie filling was good but way too much Graham cracker crust. I ended up taking some off whenever I had it. I normally buy a frozen one a bit cheaper and I think I prefer it

I love everything about this pie. I never liked key lime pie before, I prefer lemon menringe all the way. But this pie is so delicious!! Just love it.