Very delicious

Amazing

DELICIOUSLY RICH

Too much crust, which was too oily. Real whipped cream would have been better than the thick whipped topping. Lime filling was just ok. Overall, not worth it.

Not enough key lime juice. Just a sweet taste with and edge of bitterness. The “whipped topping” is not for human consumption. Buy their apple pie instead!

I have been to Sam's several times for other items, all the while, looking for the famous Key Lime Pie. I finally found one!!! This pie is so dang tasty. I concur with the stellar reviews by the masses of Sam's Club. this pie is on my list for next time. Thank you for your suggestion everyone!!!

We have been buying this pie for years! Sometimes it's our only reason for going to Sam's Club. We've bought it for special occasions and days when we just want a treat! You can't beat the value. The crust and filling are amazing. The only thing I would change is the whipped topping. It's definitely not my favorite, but I just scrape it off.

Your key lime pie was so indescribably delicious! It was better than any homemade key lime pie’s I’ve ever had. The graham cracker crust was amazing & flavorful! It was a great price too! I definitely would buy it again for my next family get together!

I always liked key lime pie, but the flavor always seemed fake. There was a sale on this one and I decided to give it a try. It is the best key lime pie I had in Paducah. It tastes just right. It is not super sweet and you can tell it was truly made with key lime pie. I would prefer less whipped cream, but it is not a bad combination.

YUM! Best served just short of frozen, for our tastes, it's not like grandma used to make, which is just fine, as I think the prep/presentation superior to grandma's. It's not like the 'real' thing, however, as it's not nearly as tart as one you'd get from the local bakery in Key West or even Miami. But for a large party, or a dinner gathering, it does the job admirably.