It was very good and fresh. Not exactly the best ever but very good for store bought. Would buy again.

Pie is pretty good for store bought. I eat it with coffee to reduce the sweetness. Could be a little more tart

Great ingredients, so basic which we love and it is incredible tang balance of sweet and creamy. Wow, Sam's Club nailed this one and hope it stays for the summer!

The flavor is pretty good but the ctust is a D- very crumbley and taste odd. Just read it is made with cookies instead of gram crackers. I would definitely not buy again.

My entire family loved this pie. It does not taste like a jello key lime pie. It has a milder lime taste that I enjoyed. For the price definitely worth a try.

I’d like to think I’m some sort of a key lime pie connoisseur, I like to get real Florida key lime pie and this was better than anything I’ve had. Seriously. So good. Sam’s needs To keep this in stock year round

The key limes should ideally come from South Florida. I have had the best Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys. This is a fair imitation of a "real" Key Lime Pie.

This is a one time purchase. Filling is light on key lime flavor, crust is good enough but the whipped topping is like a bad KoolWhip. Not impressed. Next time I'll get a frozen one from the supermarket.

The white fluff looks pretty but not tastey. More like marshmallow cream or something. Just have pie. No flufff. No tart kick. Wasnt what we expected. Very pretty though. 🫤

This is by far the best key lime pie I've had since homemade, it has such an amazing take me back home taste, I will always by it when I see it at the bakery