The crust is very buttery and the lime filling is very creamy and a bit less tart than I'm used to. I like both of those points. But the whipped topping is basically the same thing as Cool Whip, a gross fake whipped "cream". I scrape that part off. If they used a real cream-based topping, it would be 5 stars.

This is the 3rd year we have waited impatiently for Sam's Key Lime Pies to arrive. I have a neighbor who has been mowing my yard, I try to get him a pie every Year. He's like me and declares hands off to any would pie snatches that drop by. Great price for a great pie.

The people on here who rated this keylime pie a 1 star..listen up. you loose 1% of your taste buds each year. So if your 70, you have lost 70% of your taste buds, its a known fact look it up.Or where ever you had it last.. maybe thats why you rated it a 1.lol. This is THE BEST KEY LIME PIE I've had in a decade. The crust is awesome a rich dark graham crumb. You can MAKE this for the price. IT is awesome pie. Publix or anywhere else doesnt even come close to this. You get twice as much for 2 times less than other stores. 5Stars from me for sure. And I'm a 5star chef!

Yummy. Texture is spot on. Firm and flavorful. I recommend.

Ok

Very good key lime pie!!

Good creamy topping. Sweet dense filling. Unfortunately no lime flavor.

IF you want a whipcream pie with no taste of key lime than this is for you

Too Sweet - needs less sugar. Have had key lime pie in Florida and it tasted nothing like this. Also the "whipped cream" was nasty!

It tastes like sugary milk and the topping has the consistency and taste of can frosting. Threw it out as it wasn't worth the calories.