Great ingredients, so basic which we love and it is incredible tang balance of sweet and creamy. Wow, Sam's Club nailed this one and hope it stays for the summer!

The flavor is pretty good but the ctust is a D- very crumbley and taste odd. Just read it is made with cookies instead of gram crackers. I would definitely not buy again.

This pie is lacking in the usual tart lime flavor that is expected with a key lime pie. We will not buy again. Also, the crust just falls apart on the plate.

The pie was good, but the “fake” whipped cream, ie: whipped topping, is horrible! It tasted like chemicals and didn’t go at all with the pie filling.

The key limes should ideally come from South Florida. I have had the best Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys. This is a fair imitation of a "real" Key Lime Pie.

This lime pie is so much better than any of the frozen kind. I tried 3 different brands and they were almost nasty because of the crust. There is no comparison!

Excellent for the price. Pie was delicious even though it had a slightly artificial lime flavor. However, the price was about half what a comparable pie would cost at a grocery store, so it was still a great deal. I will purchase again.

I never cared too much for key lime pie but this one is delicious. My family loves it. I like that the key lime isn't tart. Everything here goes together beautifully.

It is unbelievable! The graham cracker crust is excellent and the whole pie is incredible and tastes homemade. Plus - the price is very reasonable. I’ll buy it again definitely!!

Sam's Key Lime Pie is the best key lime I've ever had and I'm a So. Florida native! Every time I serve this on holidays or bring it to a pot luck, people absolutely love it!