First time of purchasing this item..didn't select while shopping, but on a "pick up order" at store. pie was NOT good..had to throw out

Purchased a second time, because it's cool, moist, thick, and flavorful. Our guests have also loved it. The price is right, even here on Oahu

Pie is pretty good for store bought. I eat it with coffee to reduce the sweetness. Could be a little more tart

Way too sweet. Threw it away. Tasted fake and chemical. Nobody in my house could stomach more than two bites

It was very good and fresh. Not exactly the best ever but very good for store bought. Would buy again.

Too sweet for a key like pie from the crust to the filling. Couldn't even finish a small slice. We ended up just throwing it out

Great price, but was so disappointed to find that there was almost no lime flavor. Frozen key lime pies have more flavor.

Filling is good, but the cream topping is too much of a sugar rush. It needs an actual whipped cream topping.

It tastes like sugary milk and the topping has the consistency and taste of can frosting. Threw it out as it wasn't worth the calories.

Too Sweet - needs less sugar. Have had key lime pie in Florida and it tasted nothing like this. Also the "whipped cream" was nasty!