Not too sweet, not too tart. Yummy! Everyone I serve this to loves it.

Plenty of yummy Key Lime Pie, better than Key Largo Publix

Was not very good it tasted old

This pie was really good, not quite grandma's. The blend of sweet and tart are very good.

It was ok. Tasted like a manufactured pie. I only ate one piece. Threw rest away. Wasn't creamy mostly plastic tasting. I was so craving key lime. Marie Callenders frozen is better. Couldn't find. Price was great.

Waste of money, very little lime flavoring. Very blah. Taste like it was made with lime juice out of a bottle and not very much of that. I bought this product twice actually just to give it another chance and ended up just throwing it away.

Rich and creamy

Delicious!! I would serve this with company! :) Graham cracker crust is generous and holds together nicely. Filling is tart and really creamy. It is definitely on par with Publix's wildly popular key lime pie. $10 is a great price as well! Sam's Club for the win!!🎉

One of the quickest Five Star Reviews ever. The crust is great, the key lime filling is excellent, and the whipped cream is solid. I would 100% buy again and recommend to any key lime pie lovers. You may be able to find a better key lime pie from a bakery but I guarantee it'll be four times the cost. Sam's Club did it again.

My entire family loves the key lime pie so much that we randomly go to sams just to see if it’s available. Based on the last couple years, it’s only available the few weeks leading up to July 4 but we were pleasantly surprised to get one in September! We’re hoping to successfully freeze a few to hold us over until next July.