Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Chicken Alfredo, priced per pound for
Member's Mark Chicken Alfredo, priced per pound
4.3 out of 5 stars
stars
5,024 ratings1,335 reviews
  1. 5 stars64% (3,237)
  2. 4 stars15% (778)
  3. 3 stars9% (455)
  4. 2 stars5% (257)
  5. 1 star6% (297)

Member photos

  • +2 images
Sort by |
Showing 281-290 of 1,335 reviews
Jul 23, 2024
Norman
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Chicken Alfredo, only Better

Overall, I liked it. To improve it I would add more chicken, more sauce. Before heating I would recommend stirring because the chicken was laid on top and the heat dried the meat excessively. I did this before serving the second day and it was much better.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Aug 30, 2022
DebR
2 out of 5 stars review

Sam's got rid of the aluminum pan

The picture is not accurate-- this dish used to come in an aluminum pan as shown; last night I pulled out the dish from the oven and it was melted plastic, completely ruined. I didn't feel safe eating it so I tossed it. I would definitely not recommend, Sam's took a great easy meal, took a cheaper way to box it, t's not worth your time now.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Jan 17, 2026
MARIE
1 out of 5 stars review

I’ve had Chicken Alfredo thousands of times. This was the worst! My grand babies normally gobble Alfredo up and in their words - this is nasty! The ratio chicken to pasta is 5 percent (had to look for it) to 85, the other percentage accounts for cheese. The worst part was the flavor. I can’t describe it.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Dec 15, 2025
ABIGAILB
4 out of 5 stars review

Try it! Even if you don’t like Alfredo!

I’m gonna start with, I don’t like Alfredo. My family does. And yet, I ate two helpings. I did doctor it up with Shammys butter and kinders garlic Parmesan seasoning to make it better. But they didn’t and they loved it! It seems pricey, but you get less at Olive Garden. I fed two adults (one who eats for 2, he’s a never ending stomach) and an older kid.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Aug 19, 2019
MH
2 out of 5 stars review

Not the same

This used to be a great go to for a quick dinner that seemed fairly good quality. Not anymore - their most recent change from fettuccine to rotini pasta, that wasn't all they changed. One of the biggest reasons to order this instead of picking up a frozen meal was that it was REAL chicken. Now it's spongy, obviously processed "all white meat" chicken, which guess what Sam's - is NOT the same as REAL chicken.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Jul 28, 2022
Flock
3 out of 5 stars review

Dislike change in container

Used to love this product and would happily had given 5 stars. However recently they have changed the container from an oven ready metal container to a plastic disposable one. The metal container was great and made clean up a cinch. However that's not the only reason it is less than stellar anymore. Along with the change in container they seem to have cut the amount of chicken that comes in this by half. You mostly end up paying for noodles with alfredo sauce and a little chicken.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Jun 29, 2019
PH is in the house
3 out of 5 stars review

A great 5 stare meal is in bad shape

This was a 5 star meal I bought it every time I was at Sam's now something and someone has ruined my favorite meal first of all where is the chicken it's gone now second the cheese in it is all but very little and too top it off the noodles have changed long string noodles the curvy round pasta noodles yuck I thought I was crazy but the last few times it's the new way and I hate it now I won't be buying this meal and it's a shame I depended on this since I have a partner away a lot so now it's one less terrific meal I'm not getting please please look into what you'll have done you ruined a 5 star meal over what ??? Now you only get cheese tasted noodles with very little chicken for taste it's not being bought by me intill it's restored to it's natural history of what it once was and it was excellent at a very long time now I refuse to buy it okay

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Mar 1, 2026
NMH
1 out of 5 stars review

Now in a fully plastic container?

I have purchased this several times and it has always come in a foil pan, until today! It’s in a clam shell plastic container, with a sticker on the top saying to remove it before reheating. It’s a hassle to transfer it without mixing in the topping cheese. And it’s not nearly as convenient anymore. I’m hoping this isn’t a permanent change. (Tried to attach a picture but I’m getting an error)

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Feb 27, 2024
Greg
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Something's not right with this one

We've got thid dish multiple times from the same store. This time it was completely different tasting. Myqife and i both took a couple of bites andagreedthat it tasted awful. Maybe the xhicken had gine bad. Not sure but we wont be buying them any longer

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650
Oct 23, 2024
Jackie
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Delicious and perfect for a quick meal

Amazingly good. Always fresh and taste great. Has become our Sunday family meal tradition. The teenage kids are always asking for this. Quick and easy. Toss in the oven and comes out warm and delicious. Never have had a bad chunk of chicken. Chicken is fresh and has great flavors. Pans are plump full so you definitely get your money worth.

Helpful?3ZS3SOQMZHAS13589509650