I can't say that all the watermelons you will find in Sam's or other places are the same. You have to to the find something good and lucky you ??

I buy watermelon at Sam's all the time. It's really a 50/50 chance. I do love their refund policy which I have use on multiple occasions.

The last 2 I've bought at Sam's have been terrible. It's one thing to by $3.00 for a bad watermelon but for $6 you expect great every time.

Dried up inside/old. Threw the entire thing in the trash. Look at the reviews— they’re accurate! Buy elsewhere.

Im good at picking watermelons and I’m always able to pick a super yummy watermelon especially in the summer

These are the best, most flavorful watermelons I’ve ever had. I’ve bought 4 already this summer and every one of them was delicious.

This was the worst watermelon I have ever eaten... will never purchase a watermelon from Sam's Club again

One of the worst watermelons I every had, 4th of July was not the same without a good sweet watermelon. Next time I'll buy from local market.

Best tasting watermelon we have purchased this year (July 2024). And the size and price is better than anywhere else.

The watermelon was a lil squishy on the outside so i thought maybe it was just bruised..nope rotten!