Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Wish-Bone Italian Dressing, 36 oz., 2 pk. for
Wish-Bone Italian Dressing, 36 oz., 2 pk.
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars758 ratings231 reviews
  1. 5 stars87% (657)
  2. 4 stars6% (44)
  3. 3 stars2% (12)
  4. 2 stars1% (5)
  5. 1 star5% (40)
Sort by |
Showing 151-160 of 231 reviews
Feb 28, 2025
Terr2
1 out of 5 stars review

Sad

I stopped buying years ago, when the formula was changed. I loved marinated steaks in the old formula and I can no longer make my pasta salad. It’s sad to change a good product. Ken’s Zesty Italian is the closest I can get. It’s not good on pasta salad either. You are no longer honoring your roots, by changing the original formula.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. Thank you for your review. We're sorry our Wishbone Italian Dressing wasn't the quality you were expecting. We'll have this feedback shared with our team. We hope you'll give us another chance and try some of our other products. We hope your day goes well.

Apr 15, 2022
jadeee
5 out of 5 stars review

literally life changing (not clickbait)

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] in my long life of 13 years i have never seen such a masterpiece. i never knew that a person could express art in the form of cooking—but oh, am i wrong. i would drink it out of the bottle if i could. no. i will. i WILL drink all of it in one moment. it would be my magnum opus; to bring the salad dressing to its full potential. people say beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but i will make it my mission to enlighten others about this miracle that you have created. thank you. though, it doesn't mean that i will stop there. i'm very glad that the creators behind this amazing brew of herbs and spices have been proud and tall. honestly, people would think that it is just good marketing; but i don't mind to compliment it. after all, it's always good to support others. - xoxo, your biggest fan

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Mar 22, 2022
Steve B
1 out of 5 stars review

Not what it used to be...

Back in the day this was the best salad dressing period. They have completely changed the recipe. It is now this thick, corn syrup infused mess. How I know it has changed is that there used to actually be a picture of a lemon on the label way back when and when you read the ingredients label there was lemon juice in the recipe. Now there is no mention of lemon juice at all. Could they experts over there dig out the old recipe from the 70's and just go back to it. It was so good back then you could drink it straight out of the glass bottle it came in. Now I wouldn't use it to marinate chicken. Please fix.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi Steve. Thanks for sharing your review of our Italian Dressing. We're sorry you're disappointed, and we're sharing your feedback with our team so your voice is heard. We understand taste preferences vary among our valued consumers and we appreciate knowing about yours. We hope you'll continue to choose some of our other Wish-Bone products and let us know what you think. Have a great day!

Nov 1, 2019
Dave
5 out of 5 stars review

Loving the Italian Dressing

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'm a fan of Wishbone Italian dressing. I like the taste, has bits of spices you can see throughout the bottle. The taste is crisp, and a little tangy. Goes great on all salads. Will continue buying, it has always been on of my favorites.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Nov 14, 2024
CMF2024
1 out of 5 stars review

Too Sweet Now- Inedible

This used to be my favorite dressing, but the recipe has changed and now its is very, very sweet. It tastes nothing like it used to! I would use this dressing in leafy salads, pasta salads, and it was a great marinade for proteins and vegetables. No longer! Why fix what was not broke? I am so disappointed.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi. Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We're truly sorry to hear about your recent experience with our Wishbone Italian Dressing. Your satisfaction is important to us, and we're concerned about the quality issue you've encountered. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and will investigate the matter. We hope your day is great.

Oct 31, 2019
RickW
5 out of 5 stars review

Great Ranch!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] wishbone ranch is a great tasting affordable ranch that everyone can enjoy! I am personally a fan of wishbone products and this ranch did not let me down. if you are looking for a great quality ranch Eddie reasonable price wishbone is your go-to brand. I recommend purchasing this product!

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Aug 14, 2024
Nanna3
1 out of 5 stars review

New Wishbone Italian recipe

My late mother would always use the wishbone Italian in a salad she made. I was gonna surprise my granddaughter with the salad as she loved it when I made it once before. Thank god it wasn't for a big family dinner. It is just aweful.🤢Guess I'm gonna have to google every product now to make sure recipes haven't been changed before using. You just lost a loyal customer. My motto... Don't fix something that isn't broken! Big fail on this one Wishbone!

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback with us. We're sorry that our Wishbone Italian Dressing fell short of your expectations. Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We'll let our team know about this review. Thanks again for reaching out to us.

Oct 28, 2019
Jules
4 out of 5 stars review

A staple in my house

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've been using this salad dressing for years. My mom used it when I was a kid so that's how I first discovered it and at the age of 36 I still use it. It's very flavorful with lots of spices. It's the only dressing my picky son will eat. I use it for cold pasta salads and it's a wonderful marinade for grilled chicken. It really adds a zesty flavor without being spicy. They have a lot of flavors but robusto Italian is always the one I go back to over and over again. I love that it doesn't contain high fructose corn syrup and it's a good source of Omega 3.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Sep 1, 2022
ExWishboneFan
1 out of 5 stars review

Not what it used to be

Inedible, it has been about 5 years since my last purchase. I put this dressing on radishes and it was inedible. I threw everything in the trash. I understand, some folks like a sweet salad dressing. I'm not one of them. I will need to look elsewhere or start making my own recipe. Very disappointing, Wishbone Robusto used to be such an excellent choice.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback with us. We're sorry you weren't happy with our Wishbone Italian Dressing. We'll make sure your voice is heard. We hope you'll give us another chance and let us know what you think of our other products. Thanks again for your review.

Aug 15, 2022
Mom2Wolf
1 out of 5 stars review

Please bring back old recipe

I have always kept Wishbone Italian Dressing on hand for years and years. I used it in salads and as a marinade. My three sons loved my chicken on the grill in the summer. I tried to make it again this summer and made a salad for myself first. I thought I had COVID-19 when I took a bite of my salad that had Wishbone Italian Dressing on it! I don’t have COVID-19, but the flavor was so different I spit it out! It was far too sweet and I could barely taste anything familiar. So, did you change the formulation of your Italian Dressing? And why? It was PERFECT just how it was! I learned to like eating salad with Wishbone Italian Salad Dressing back in the 1960s. Please, you had it perfect, go back to the traditional recipe.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi. Thanks for considering to share your experience with us. We're sorry you think our new Wishbone Italian Dressing was a bit sweeter than you anticipated. We'll let our team know about this feedback. We hope you'll give us another chance and will let us know what you think of our other products. Have a nice day.