Big Pie! Excellent bake which is hard to do in that size. Loved the crunchy caramelized crust, the apples were sliced thick so gave it texture, not too soft, not too crunchy. Could have used slightly more cinnamon but they must cater to the masses. Overall better than other stores. Only apple pie that I will buy again.

So disappointed, always look forward to Sam’s apple pie, but this one missed the mark by a mile. The top lattice crust was so hard that you could not get through certain strips with a fork. Sloppy presentation where the filling was out over the sides and was gelatinous looking and tasting. Tried to pick the best one on the table but unfortunately none were that great. I know Sam’s can do better; they usually do.

The pie is always delicious! My only suggestion would be to offer a personal size version. The 12 inch version is massive and great for families, however I'm single and forced to eat the whole thing in two days because of the use by date...maybe that's why I'm single.

I recently purchased an apple pie from Sam’s Club, and unfortunately, it didn’t meet my expectations. The crust was overcooked and burnt, which overshadowed the flavor of the filling. Additionally, I noticed the pie was set to expire in just two days, which was disappointing for something I planned to serve later in the week. I expected better quality and freshness for the price.

This is one of the best apple pies I've encountered at any store. It was very flavorful and had enough "sauce" so it wasn't dry. The crust was excellent. It's extra large, especially for a couple. I actually froze a couple of pieces for after the holidays.

I am really picky about baked goods and am considered a good baker among my circle. I seldom buy premade baked goods but was pressed for time and bought the Apple pie for a gathering. It got rave reviews from those that enjoyed the pie. I'm not hanging up my rolling pin just yet but it's nice to know there is a great product to enjoy when you don't feel like baking yourself. The pie was generously filled with lots of apples too, very nice for a premade pie.

The Member’s Mark Apple Lattice Pie was the best apple pie I’ve ever had! It tastes great, it’s not too sweet, cuts nicely, and slides right out of the pan. The pan and lid combination worked great, and helped keep the pie fresh in our cold garage for over a week. And the price was really good for the size of the pie and the quality.

I bought this pie for Christmas and it was well liked by everyone. The apple filling was a little too sweet for me, but the crust was delicious. It's big and will serve a lot of people. My son took the leftover pie back to his place and his roommates devoured it.

Great apple pie for the price. It’s the best when it is fresh. After a few days the crust gets a bit soggy, but that is true of most pies. Problem is that this pie is so big it takes a while to get through it, and by then it’s not as fresh. Great if you are feeding a large gathering though.

I have bought this pie twice and the first time I bought it it was great. For the price you can't go wrong, it will feed 8 people easily with leftovers for later. What I didn't like was that the second time I bought it the quality was subpar, the first pie was great with taste and just the right softness to the whole pie and crust. the second pie was hard and had a different taste to it. So basically you may like it one purchase but not get the same quality the nexxt.