We used to love these when we bought them in the original packaging shown (red box). However, in the most recent box we got (white box), the fish was far more oily, did not taste as good, and the breading was soggier and seemed wrong. The previous product of the same name was restaurant quality. It made you want to eat more. This is tolerable.

After not having their beer battered cod fillets for a while, we were happy to see them available again. Unfortunately, their "new formulation" is a total disappointment and doesn't measure up to the previous product. The taste is very bland and had to be slathered with tartar sauce to be decent. Plus there was an odd, unpleasant taste that was difficult to describe until I saw another reviewer mention that it contains aluminum. That has to be the odd taste. Additionally, I am not happy that the package says it is "Processed in the USA" intentionally avoiding mentioning the source of the ingredients. We deserve to know where our food originated. I will not knowingly consume any food items from China, and I suspect that is where most of the ingredients were acquired. We will be purchasing beer battered cod fillets elsewhere from now on.

For years, we bought beer-battered cod from Sam's (the older 2.5 lb box) because it was an excellent frozen fish product. We had this for dinner at least once/week. Well, this disappeared from our local warehouses about 2 years ago, and their " replacement" product is absolutely horrible. The coating is far too thin, falls off easily during baking, and is relatively tasteless. The previous beer-battered cod was 1000% better. PLEASE bring back the older beer-battered cod. (Makes one wonder if Sam's actually reads any of these reviews).

The directions basically have us cook these small fish pieces into more than half the size they started. It turns the breading too dark of brown, the fish turns dry, and extremely overcooked. The fish itself is without flavor, but the breading is seasoned ok. I won't purchase this again.

The batter is thick and greasy. I think the beer flavor is just right, but these are really really small. Hardly thick enough for a sandwich. They need to cut these fillets thicker and 1/4 an inch. Probably won't buy again until I see this same box that says "new and improved".

I bought these before and they were great. The last box I bought was terrible. I just cooked 4 pieces of fish and couldn't eat 2 of them because they were very hard and chewy and tasted bad. They seemed to be cut different. The other 2 were flaky and good. Not worth the gamble to see if they are good or not.

Tiny, irregular shaped scraps of fish. Bag had multiple pieces too tiny to cover a small hamburger bun; it's just junk pieces of fish. You have to oil fry or you'll get a mush ball and even fried they are a disappointment. The good news is, that horrible "warm skunk beer" flavor is done...for now anyway!

I used an air fryer and exactly followed the directions on the box. They turned out unpleasantly mushy. On the flavor side, they didn’t taste too fishy so that’s a plus. I also like that they are wild-caught, if that’s actually true. One piece out of the five I made was inedible because it had hard strands of what seemed to be gristle throughout. I’ll try again and use an oven next time, but only because I hate to waste food. Will not be buying again.

We have been buying these for a couple years and they have been great until recently. Something has changed with the recipe and we will no longer be our chasing these. I have 4 boxes in the freezer that nobody wants to eat. Bring the old recipe back.

Honestly, not too bad for frozen beaded fish.