I’ve been buying this product for more than 5 years. Suddenly, they had an extreme amount of salt to the product, making it not eatable. If they don’t correct the manufacturing problem, I will try Costco’s version. I wish there was someway to get a refund for this purchase.

The batter is thick and greasy. I think the beer flavor is just right, but these are really really small. Hardly thick enough for a sandwich. They need to cut these fillets thicker and 1/4 an inch. Probably won't buy again until I see this same box that says "new and improved".

These were really good - there were a lot of filets in the bag and they batter stayed on them. We cooked them in the air fryer and its something the kids can do for themselves too. They had a good flavor - not that odd frozen fishy taste. The filets were a bit smaller than i anticipated but they were thick in size - all in all we liked them and will be buying them again. They are a better price value than ones I have seen at competitors.

I cooked six pieces of this fish. Have photos of the hard gray skin areas that we couldn't even chew from three of the pieces, plus about a one inch piece of (not flimsy) bone. We plan to throw the remainder of the box in the trash. First time I've had a bad experience with a MM product. So disappointed!

We used to love these when we bought them in the original packaging shown (red box). However, in the most recent box we got (white box), the fish was far more oily, did not taste as good, and the breading was soggier and seemed wrong. The previous product of the same name was restaurant quality. It made you want to eat more. This is tolerable.

Dense and chewing

I used an air fryer and exactly followed the directions on the box. They turned out unpleasantly mushy. On the flavor side, they didn’t taste too fishy so that’s a plus. I also like that they are wild-caught, if that’s actually true. One piece out of the five I made was inedible because it had hard strands of what seemed to be gristle throughout. I’ll try again and use an oven next time, but only because I hate to waste food. Will not be buying again.

I bought these before and they were great. The last box I bought was terrible. I just cooked 4 pieces of fish and couldn't eat 2 of them because they were very hard and chewy and tasted bad. They seemed to be cut different. The other 2 were flaky and good. Not worth the gamble to see if they are good or not.

Apparently they get this fish from a different supplier, not even sure it's Cod anymore. The appearance alone changed quite a bit, MUCH smaller pieces and cut in strips, nothing like the picture on the box anymore. The taste was NOT good, it was like eating a piece of sponge! I know we having supply chain issues but that's NO excuse for giving people crappy food AND it had less n the box and the price has increased....of course.

Tiny, irregular shaped scraps of fish. Bag had multiple pieces too tiny to cover a small hamburger bun; it's just junk pieces of fish. You have to oil fry or you'll get a mush ball and even fried they are a disappointment. The good news is, that horrible "warm skunk beer" flavor is done...for now anyway!