We got two, first one we ordered online and it was completely thawed and the size of a chicken. Went inside the next day and bought a large frozen one!

It was a good turkey, but I also prepared some Butter Ball turkeys at the same time and I thought they were a little higher quality. Cleaned up better, less pin feathers still attached, etc.

Cooked according to directions. Basted every 30 minutes. Looked beautiful......but the toughest turkey I've ever eaten. What you would expect from an old turkey but not a young one.

I bought this turkey thinking it would be fresh not frozen. I’ve never seen a turkey advertised as “RAW”. It was like a skinny chicken. 16lbs and very dry and tough. I guess I should go back to Butterball.

Advertised as fresh turkey but was partially frozen and thawed. Couldn’t find the temperature button (was hidden under wing) and legs stuck out so didn’t fit in normal turkey pan

Dry, leather-like texture, even before roasting. After roasting it was chewy. I was glad I wasn't feeding a large crowd this year, I would have been embarrassed. Very disappointing.

I appreciate the lower sodium content in these turkeys. It can be difficult to find turkeys that don't have sky high sodium levels so I will continue to purchase my turkeys (I bought maybe 6 or 7 this year) from Sam's.

We bought a 9 lb. Members Mark turkey and were very disappointed. My husband always makes a delicious turkey on the smoker. Even though the turkey was not dry, the meat was tough, even a bit difficult to cut.

Purchased this turkey, cooked it like a normal 12lb turkey and the flavor was awful. Not really sure what happened, cooked hundreds of turkeys. Definitely won’t buy this from Dams again.

Spongy, stringy, and totally flavorless. This wasn't a cooking issue — the bird itself was the problem. Member's Mark turkeys are heavily injected with “solution” that makes the meat rubbery and watery, and Sam's Club is known for meats that have been frozen, thawed, and refrozen, which destroys the texture even more. If you want real turkey flavor and normal texture, go with a fresh, not injected turkey (Butterball Fresh, Bell %26 Evans, Amish/local). Cheap bird = disappointing holiday. Save yourself the headache.