I bought these protein shakes because they are a Members's Mark product which usually means good quality as well as price. These shakes are too thick to easily drink, I feel I need a spoon.

This is your typical run of the mill protein shake. It’s chocolate flavored and has. Good amount of protein in it. I’m not a fan of the ingredient list but to each is own. If you like chocolate protein shakes, I say give a shot.

I assume that Sam's replaced the High Protein shake in red cartons with these. They have all the same ingredients but not the same taste. I sure wish I could get the red ones again.

This product is supposed to replace the Chocolate Member's Mark Protein Drink 18-pack. It doesn't quite have the same taste, and I dislike the aftertaste it has. I don't recommend this buy. Poor replacement from Sam’s Club.

When my store was out of Fairlife I thought I would give these a try. I wasn't able to finish one. There was a smell and aftertaste that was unsatisfactory.

I was hoping these would taste similar to premier protein shakes but unfortunately they are hard to drink, taste chalky and have an unpleasant and artificial taste.

This protein shake tasted like any other chocolate protein shake. Nothing super special about it. Tastes like it has almond milk in it so it has a little bit of a nutty flavor but could’ve been more chocolaty in my opinion.

disappointed -- 15 bottles, not 18 and the price is the same...doesn't seem right. Guess it was the thing to do since there is new pkging.... didn't think we would miss the extra 3 bottles...

I have a protein shake every day and I decided to try these because they were at a better price point. I probably won't get them again. The flavor just isn't as rich as the other brands.

A few of them were Congealed, like pudding consistency. Idk if they changed the recipe when the packaging changed or what, but now it’s one less safe food for my child with ARFID